Chestnut Hill · on Cresheim Creek · after 1842

Patterson’s Flour MillPatterson's Flour Mill

A mill in three sentences

A mill in three sentences

Some mills in this collection left deeds, tax lists, maps, and lawsuits. Patterson’s Flour Mill left three sentences. It stood on Cresheim Creek — the tributary that runs down to join Wissahickon Creek — on the reach just above the lower Bechtel mill and below the upper one. Everything known about it comes from one paragraph of S. F. Hotchkin’s Ancient and Modern Germantown, Mount Airy and Chestnut Hill (1889), where Hotchkin prints the account given him by David Hinkle, of the creek’s own milling family:

“Mr. Hill tore down the old lower mill and erected a new one. He purchased Patterson’s flour mill, just above, for his work. Colonal Kester was the next owner.”

That paragraph is the beginning and the end of this mill’s literature. No deed, directory line, map face, or newspaper item naming a Patterson or a Kester mill on Cresheim Creek has been found to stand beside it.

Patterson, Hill, and “Colonel” Kester

Of Patterson himself, nothing survives but the surname — no first name, no dates, in anything read. What survives is that he owned a working flour mill, and that a neighbouring miller found it worth buying. Joseph Hill, the miller of the lower Bechtel mill, had just torn down the old lower mill and erected a new one; he then purchased Patterson’s flour mill, just above, “for his work.” The purchase reads as an expansion of water or room for the Hill operation. Hotchkin gives it no date: Hill’s rebuilding of the lower mill belongs to the years after Peter Bechtel Jr.’s death in January 1842, and the Patterson purchase is printed inside that same loose bracket, no tighter.

The next owner was a man Hotchkin calls “Colonal Kester” — the spelling is Hotchkin’s own. A surname and a militia-style title are all the record gives: no first name, no dates, no product stated. Nothing read connects this Kester to any other record.

The mill the maps do not name

No map read names Patterson’s mill. Charles Ellet Jr.’s map of Philadelphia County (1843), read along this reach of Cresheim Creek, shows in it only a Spice Mill, between Bechtel’s Paper Mill and Carr’s Cotton Factory. Whether Patterson’s flour mill and the map’s Spice Mill were the same ground at different dates is a question nothing read answers: the map gives a product, Hotchkin gives a surname, and no source joins them. It stands here as an open possibility, not a claim.

One confusion can be cleared — carefully. The Hinkle family had a flour mill of their own on this creek, and it might be wondered whether Patterson’s mill and the Hinkle mill were one seat under two tellings. In the same account, a few sentences earlier, Hotchkin places Jesse Hinkle’s flour mill above the upper mill — a different reach from Patterson’s, which stood just above the lower one. On the only testimony that names Patterson at all, the two are distinct seats, and the overlap does not arise. The caution is printed with the answer: that geography rests on one informant in one book, uncorroborated by any map or record read, and Hotchkin’s order of the creek’s seats stands in conflict with Ellet’s 1843 map elsewhere along it. Even on Ellet’s order, though, “just above” still places Patterson’s beside the lower mill — the overlap does not arise on either reading.

What the record does not say

Of the working mill, almost nothing can be told. It was a flour mill — the product is in its name in the source. Its scale, its buildings, its power beyond the creek itself, and its workforce are all unrecorded in anything read. The end is likewise unrecorded: the mill enters the record already built, changes hands twice in three sentences, and leaves no further trace in the sources reached — no fire, no sale, no demolition, no taking. Nothing on the ground today is attributed to this seat in any source read.

Two records could settle much of this, and neither can be read online. The 1850 and 1860 Census of Manufactures schedules for this ward of the city are not freely readable on the internet. And Macfarlan’s The Wissahickon Mills (1949), the standard succession work for the valley’s mills, survives only as a physical typescript at the Free Library —, a permanent gap. If a deed, a manufactures schedule, or a reading of Macfarlan ever names Patterson or Kester on Cresheim Creek, this account reopens at once.

Patterson’s mill is not so much untold as unrecorded. This page exists so that the seat is counted, placed, and its thinness printed — rather than padded.

Timeline

1842Peter Bechtel Jr. dies in January; Joseph Hill’s rebuilding of the lower Bechtel mill, and his undated purchase of Patterson’s flour mill, belong to the years that follow.
1843Ellet’s map of Philadelphia County shows a Spice Mill in the reach above the lower Bechtel mill; no map read names Patterson’s mill.
1889Hotchkin prints the only known account of the mill, from David Hinkle’s telling.

The Cellar

Sources

  1. S. F. Hotchkin, Ancient and Modern Germantown, Mount Airy and Chestnut Hill (1889), pp. 362–363 — read in full. The Patterson passage and the Jesse Hinkle flour-mill passage, both quoted in this account; the source of every statement here about the mill’s seat, its owners, and its separation from the Hinkle seat.
  2. Charles Ellet Jr., map of Philadelphia County (1843) — face read. The order of seats up Cresheim Creek: Bechtel’s Paper Mill, the Spice Mill, Carr’s Cotton Factory, the France Carpet & Dye Works, Hinkle’s Grist Mill. No Patterson mill is named on it.
  3. This collection’s figure list of the valley’s mills — consulted for this seat’s place in the Cresheim Creek order and for the Census of Manufactures check named for these seats; not a source for any fact about the mill itself.

Printed gaps and conflicts


A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, it is welcome here — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home