The Holgate fulling mill stood — most likely — on Wissahickon Creek in Roxborough, on the creek frontage of a tract that ran from the Schuylkill River across to the creek, just south of today’s Hermit’s Lane. A fulling mill is a cloth-finishing mill: heavy wooden hammers, worked by water power, beat woven woollen cloth in water, cleansing it and thickening it until the fibres lock together. Julius Sachse, who wrote of the German Pietists of the province, calls this the first fulling mill on the Wissahickon.
The family name comes down in two spellings — Holgate and Houlgate — and both are kept here, as the records give them. No picture of the mill survives: no drawing, no photograph, and the old maps do not even name it. What survives is the record, and the record has gaps and disagreements. They are printed here as they stand.
The founder
Mathew Holgate — spelled Houlgate in several of the records — came to Philadelphia as a young Quaker. The family’s compiled genealogy says he arrived on August 31, 1685, on the Rebecca of Liverpool, carrying a letter of certification from Marsden Monthly Meeting.
On March 18, 1698, John Jennett sold him eighty acres adjoining the Hermitage tract — land that ran from the Schuylkill River to the line of Germantown township. On that ground Holgate built his fulling mill.
When? The records disagree. Sachse dates the building to 1720 and adds, dryly, that in the undertaking Houlgate “does not seem to have prospered.” Joseph Miles, in his history of Roxborough, says the mill went up before 1720. John Daly, writing in 1922, gives 1698 — but 1698 is the year of the land purchase, and Daly’s date reads as the two events pressed into one.
Where did it stand?
The accounts disagree about the ground as well as the year. Miles puts the mill on the Wissahickon “below Conrad’s Lane.” Daly puts it “some distance further up Paper Mill Run” — a different stream altogether, the Monoshone in Germantown. The land record sides with the creek: when the tract was sold, it was described as running from the Schuylkill to the Wissahickon, with 53 perches of frontage along the creek, south of the line of the present Hermit Lane. Weighed together, Miles, Sachse, and the tract description put the founder’s mill on the main creek, on that frontage below Hermit’s Lane. That is the best the record allows — probable, not proven.
The sheriff’s sale
Whatever the mill earned, it did not keep the family its ground. Within a generation, the founder’s eighty acres were sold at sheriff’s sale to Peter Righter. Here, too, the records give two dates: a study of the Righter family gives September 11, 1725; Sachse gives December 6, 1728. They may be two sales, or one event twice misdated. Both dates are printed as found. No standard account of the family mentions the sale at all — yet it is the paper trail behind Sachse’s dry verdict that the mill “does not seem to have prospered.”
The Holgates themselves stayed in Roxborough. The family also built the stone dwelling on Rittenhouse Lane — Red Bridge Lane — later owned by George Markle. That house is a dwelling, not the mill. It is named here only so that it is not mistaken for one.
A fulling mill again
The story does not end with the sale. Fifty years on, the tax lists put a fulling mill back in Holgate hands in Roxborough — and whose ground it stood on, no record read explains. If the founder’s tract was gone by the 1720s, the later mill stood on land the family still held or had won back, or on another family seat altogether. The record does not say.
Mathew Holgate Jr., of Roxborough, made his will on January 5, 1770; it was proved on February 26 of that year. His wife was Mary, and his sons John and William were his executors. In 1774, John Houlgate was assessed in Roxborough with a fulling mill on 175 acres.
John’s own will was proved on August 1, 1778. So when Horatio Gates Jones made his situated list of the creek’s mills in 1779, he taxed “John Houlgate’s estate” on one line and a Matthew Houlgate on the next. The list catches the mill in mid-handover, between a dead man and his successor.
Jones names the mill itself “Matthew Holget and Christian Snyder’s fulling mill.” The Matthew of 1779 belongs to the family’s third generation. The compiled genealogy’s Matthew of that generation is a militia officer — a second lieutenant in the Flying Camp in 1776, a captain in 1778, and lieutenant colonel of the 7th (Germantown) Battalion from July 31, 1779. That the miller and the colonel were one man is the genealogy’s placement, not a thing any record read here proves. Of Christian Snyder, Jones is the only voice: nothing else read touches him.
Jones’s list raises one more problem it does not settle. He sets the fulling mill seventh of eleven mills, between Abraham Rittenhouse’s and Peter Care’s. If his order follows the creek, that puts the mill well up the valley — fitting neither Hermit’s Lane nor Paper Mill Run. The seat of the 1779 mill is unfixed.
Two other mills with the name
Two more fulling mills carry the name, and neither is this one. A William Houlgate was assessed with a fulling mill in Gwynedd in 1774 — Montgomery County ground, outside this story. And a deed of April 1, 1783, bounds a Germantown mill lot by “William Houlgate’s fulling mill land” — a namesake seat on the Germantown side, on the Cresheim waters. The name travelled; the mills were not the same, and they are not merged here.
The road, and the end
One survival attaches to the name. Daly records the tradition that in October 1777, General Armstrong advanced over the Holgate’s Mill Road — “then the most direct route from Roxborough to Germantown.” Half a century after the founder built, his mill still named the road a general marched on.
Of the later mill’s end, nothing was found: no closing, no sale, no taking. It leaves the record with Jones’s list of 1779. The founder’s mill has the stranger ending. Its ruins stood into the age of the turnpike, and Miles gives their fate in one sentence: they “have lately been covered up by the workmen engaged in making the Wissahiccon turnpike.” The mill was not torn down. It was buried where it stood, under the making of the drive — and nothing on the ground today marks where.
Timeline
| Year | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1685 | Mathew Holgate arrives at Philadelphia on August 31, on the Rebecca of Liverpool | Holgate genealogy compilation |
| 1698 | John Jennett sells Holgate eighty acres, on March 18 | Sachse, from Patent Book A, p. 104 |
| 1720 | The fulling mill is built — the first on the Wissahickon (Miles says before 1720; Daly says 1698) | Sachse; Miles; Daly |
| 1725 / 1728 | The founder’s eighty acres are sold at sheriff’s sale to Peter Righter — the two dates stand as found | Righter family study; Sachse |
| 1770 | Mathew Holgate Jr.’s will is made on January 5 and proved on February 26 | Will Book O, p. 469, via the genealogy compilation |
| 1774 | John Houlgate is assessed in Roxborough with a fulling mill on 175 acres | Pennsylvania tax lists (the project’s SWEEP-26) |
| 1777 | Tradition: General Armstrong advances over the Holgate’s Mill Road, in October | Daly, The Wissahickon, pp. 25–26 |
| 1778 | John Houlgate’s will is proved, on August 1 | Holgate genealogy compilation |
| 1779 | Jones’s list names “Matthew Holget and Christian Snyder’s” fulling mill; the tax list carries John Houlgate’s estate | Jones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187; SWEEP-26 |

