Roxborough · on Wissahickon Creek · early 1700s, last traced 1794

Hermit’s Lane Grist MillHermit’s Lane Grist Mill

A small grist mill on the creek, built by a Vandaren and a Rittenhouse, argued over in the Revolution — and remembered today by the lane its owner fought to open

The Hermit’s Lane grist mill stood on Wissahickon Creek in Roxborough, not far from the present Hermit’s Lane — today’s Hermit Lane — where the lane runs down from Ridge Avenue to the creek at Hermit’s Lane Bridge. That placing is from John M. Daly’s The Wissahickon (1922), and it is the one direct statement of place that any source read for this story makes. No map read names this mill, and no picture of it survives. Photographs of the lane and its bridge do survive, but they show the lane, not the mill, and they are not used here as if they did. What the mill left behind is the lane itself.

The mill was a grist mill — a mill that ground grain into meal and flour. Beyond that, its working record is thin. Nothing read gives its stones, its buildings, its hands, or its output. Its one firm fact is a legal one: for most of its life it had no proper outlet to Ridge Road, and in 1794 its owner went through the courts to open one. That road is Hermit’s Lane.

Built very early

The whole building record is one sentence. Daly writes: “The mill of John Vandaren and Enoch Rittenhouse, built very early in the 18th Century was situated not far from the present Hermit’s Lane.” On that sentence the mill goes back to the early 1700s, and two men built it: John Vandaren and Enoch Rittenhouse.

Enoch Rittenhouse is a problem, and he is printed here as one. No other source read names an Enoch Rittenhouse of the building generation. The family’s own record, set out in the RittenhouseTown landmark nomination, knows its Enochs two generations later — among them Enoch, son of Jacob Rittenhouse, who with his brother Samuel kept the family’s mills on the Monoshone after 1811. Daly’s co-builder is carried in this story exactly as Daly gives him. The partnership is not doubted; the man’s identity is untraced.

The 1777 argument

In the Revolution, the name Vandaren’s lands in an argument that is still not settled. Daly puts this mill at the centre of it. General Armstrong’s report on the Battle of Germantown gave his objective as “Vanduring’s,” and Daly holds that the Vandaren mill Armstrong was making for was this one, at Hermit’s Lane.

Another account points the name down the creek. Brandt’s 1927 history, and the creek-mouth record gathered for this project, attach the name “Vandaren’s Mills” — and Washington’s order of march of October 3, 1777, which names the head of John Van Deering’s mill dam — to the Robeson seat at the mouth of the creek. Both accounts are printed here, and neither is followed silently. A list made two years later shows why the argument exists at all: there were two Vandaren mills on this creek.

Three Rittenhouses

In 1779 Horatio Gates Jones set down the eleven mills of Roxborough, placed in creek order. First comes John Vandaren’s grist mill, “now owned by the Robesons” — the creek-mouth seat. Second comes “John Vandaren and Martin Rittenhouse’s grist mill.” Read in creek order, as Jones presents the list, the second seat — the next one above the Robesons’ — is this mill. And by 1779 the Rittenhouse partner of record is Martin, not Enoch. How the share passed from Enoch to Martin is nowhere recorded. The list implies the succession, and it is printed at that grade.

In 1794 the partner’s name is gone from the firm altogether. Daly records Michael Rittenhouse as then sole owner of Vandaren’s. How Michael was related to Martin, no source read states. Michael is the last named holder of the mill in anything read. So across one small mill’s century, three Rittenhouses stand in the record: Enoch the builder, on Daly’s word alone; Martin, in 1779; and Michael, sole owner by 1794. The usual accounts print only Daly’s first sentence and drop the mill at the Revolution.

The lane

The mill’s one measurable fact is the lane. Until 1794 it had no proper outlet to Ridge Road. That year, after much litigation — the words are Daly’s — Hermit’s Lane was opened as a private way, giving Michael Rittenhouse an outlet from his grist mill to Ridge Road.

But the lane was not the miller’s work alone, and the family on the other side of the fence line kept its own record. The Righter family study, working from the Righters’ partition papers, shows the lane began as the Righters’ own: a cartway one perch wide — a perch is an old measure, about sixteen and a half feet — laid out in the partition agreement of 1787 among the Righter heirs, whose lots ran from Ridge Road down to the creek. When the cartway was opened as a private road in 1794, it crossed Michael Righter’s land by an irregular route from the creek, and the man paid for the damage was Michael Righter: £10. In 1804 the lane became a public road, 33 feet wide.

The end is not recorded

When this mill stopped, and how, no source read says. There is no closing, no fire, no flood, and no demolition in its record. Ellet’s map of the county, made in 1843, names no mill at Hermit’s Lane. By then the seat was gone, idle, or too small to name.

Two later traces may be this mill in a later form. They are printed here as leads, not as its end. Map indexes of 1862 and 1865 name a “Rittenhouse Mill” on the creek at Shur’s Lane, the next lane below Hermit’s Lane. Whether that mill is this seat in a later generation, or a separate small seat of the same family, no source read proves. And Jane Mork Gibson’s account of the Fairmount Park Commission’s first purchases lists the Wissahickon ground the Commission began to acquire in 1868, the mills of Nicholas Rittenhouse and Henry Rittenhouse among it. Gibson gives the Commission’s general pattern: taken buildings “were torn down or became derelict and decayed,” and the WPA finished the work in the 1930s. If a Henry Rittenhouse mill on this reach was this seat’s last form, its end may have followed that pattern. It is not printed here as this mill’s proven fate.

What remains

Today the seat is parkland: the lane, the bridge, and the woods above the creek. No source read identifies a mill foundation or a race on the ground. The mill is gone from the maps and gone from the ground. What it left is a road: Hermit Lane still runs from Ridge Avenue down to the creek — the outlet a mill owner litigated into being in 1794.

Timeline

YearEventSource
Early 1700sThe mill is built by John Vandaren and Enoch Rittenhouse, not far from the present Hermit’s LaneDaly, The Wissahickon (1922), pp. 26–27
1777Armstrong’s report names “Vanduring’s” as his objective; Daly holds it was this mill — Brandt (1927) and the creek-mouth record give the name to the Robeson seatDaly (1922); Brandt (1927)
1779Jones lists “John Vandaren and Martin Rittenhouse’s grist mill” second among Roxborough’s eleven millsJones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187
1787The Righter partition agreement lays out the one-perch cartway that becomes Hermit’s LaneRighter family study
1794After litigation the lane opens as a private way; Michael Rittenhouse is sole owner of the mill; Michael Righter receives £10 for damage to his landDaly (1922); Righter family study
1804The lane becomes a public road, 33 feet wideRighter family study
1843Ellet’s county map names no mill at Hermit’s LaneEllet, Map of the County of Philadelphia (1843)
1862 / 1865Map indexes name a “Rittenhouse Mill” at Shur’s Lane — a lead only, not proven to be this seatAtlas of the City of Philadelphia (1862); Barnes’s map
1868The Fairmount Park Commission begins acquiring Wissahickon sites, the mills of Nicholas Rittenhouse and Henry Rittenhouse among them — a lead onlyGibson, Workshop of the World (1990)

The Cellar

The accounts of the mill and the lane (read)

  1. John M. Daly, The Wissahickon (1922), pp. 26–27 — the mill of John Vandaren and Enoch Rittenhouse, “not far from the present Hermit’s Lane”; the 1794 opening of the lane after much litigation; Michael Rittenhouse “then sole owner of Vandaren’s”; the Armstrong/“Vanduring’s” argument. Read in full text at archive.org.
  2. Horatio Gates Jones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187 — the situated list of Roxborough’s eleven mills of 1779: John Vandaren’s grist mill “(now owned by the Robesons)” first, and “John Vandaren and Martin Rittenhouse’s grist mill” second. Cited at that grade: the list is quoted verbatim in the Holgate genealogy compilation (freepages.rootsweb.com) and in substance in the Ridge Avenue nomination and the Roxborough–Manayunk Historical Context Statement, all read; the book was not re-read page-for-page in this pass.
  3. A Study of the Righter Family of Roxborough Township in the 18th Century (archive.org) — Hermit Lane as the one-perch-wide cartway of the 1787 partition agreement; the 1794 opening as a private road; Michael Righter’s £10 damage payment, citing Jones, “Historical Notes of Roxborough and Manayunk,” pp. 71–72; the lane a public road, 33 feet wide, in 1804.
  4. Jane Mork Gibson, Workshop of the World (Oliver Evans Press, 1990), Fairmount Park chapter — the list of Wissahickon sites the Fairmount Park Commission began to acquire in 1868, including the mills of Edward H. Amidown, Nicholas Rittenhouse, and Henry Rittenhouse; the general pattern for taken buildings — “torn down or became derelict and decayed,” the WPA finishing the work in the 1930s. Read at workshopoftheworld.com.

Map and index records (read)

  1. Free Library of Philadelphia digital indexes — Atlas of the City of Philadelphia, 1862, Section 20 (item 12334): “Rittenhouse Mill: Shur’s Land [Lane] and Wissahickon Creek above Falls of Schuylkill”; Barnes, New Map of the Consolidated City, 1855 (item MBARAA00001, via DPLA): “Rittenhouse Mill: Wissahickon Creek at Shur’s Lane”; Ellet, Map of the County of Philadelphia, 1843 (item 11764): the Roxborough named sites, with no mill at Hermit’s Lane. (The mill dossier’s text dates the Barnes index to 1865; its bibliography files the item consulted as the 1855 map above. Both datings are printed, as the dossier carries them.)

The family record (read)

  1. National Park Service, National Historic Landmark nomination, RittenhouseTown Historic District (1993), §§7–8 — the Rittenhouse family’s generations: the Enochs the record knows belong two generations later than Daly’s co-builder, among them Enoch, son of Jacob Rittenhouse, who with his brother Samuel maintained the family’s Monoshone mills after 1811. Read at npgallery.nps.gov.

Project files

  1. The biography project’s master list — entries 26 (John Vanderen: two mills in 1779, and the creek-mouth mill named in Washington’s Germantown orders), 35 (Michael Rittenhouse), and 36 (Enoch Rittenhouse, with the generations-unresolved flag); and the mills index, entry 4 (Hermit’s Lane Grist Mill).

A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, the project welcomes it — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home