At the top of the Wissahickon valley, where Germantown Township met Springfield Manor — in the corridor of today’s City Line and Northwestern Avenue — a paper mill was at work by 1710. The Crefeld tract lay in Germantown Township, in the County of Philadelphia; the deeds settle the county question, and this seat stands on the Philadelphia side of the creek. One description differs in its wording, and it is printed as it stands: Jones, writing in the Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, describes the tract as on the “west side of the Wissahickon,” while the deeds place it in Germantown Township. Both stand. Nothing of the mill itself stands in any source read. The best ground-level locator is an old man’s tree: Daly, writing in 1922, noted a great European elm, already over a hundred years old, growing “near the site of the Dewee’s Mill at Germantown Avenue and the creek,” with an old silver maple due north of it in what had been the Convent Garden. A tree noted in 1922 is a period locator, no more — but it is the closest thing to a marker this mill has.
The builder
The builder was William DeWees (about 1677–1745), born at Leeuwarden, according to his family’s historian, and brought to Germantown in 1689 or 1690 with his brother-in-law Nicholas Rittenhouse, a papermaker of the family whose mill on the Monoshone, built in 1690, was the first paper mill in British North America. DeWees was sheriff of Germantown in 1704. In 1710 he built his paper mill at Crefeld. That December, in the very year the mill rose, Isaac Van Vlecq lent “Willem DeWees” £5 in light money, repayable the following May; £2 7s of it was repaid. It is a small loan set against a mill, and it is printed here as the record gives it — a glimpse of how thin the money under these first mills ran.
The second paper mill in America?
The sources describe the Crefeld mill as the second paper mill in America, after Rittenhouse’s of 1690. That is the sources’ framing, and it is printed at that grade: Jones is the early printed anchor for it, and when Gibson repeats the claim in her Chestnut Hill chapter, her own footnote shows where she got it — a 1949 typescript by D. Macfarlan that survives only as a physical copy and has not been read for this account. The 1710 date itself rests on firmer ground: the deed record.
The deed of 1713
That deed is the anchor of everything known about this mill. On December 15, 1713, William DeWees sold the 100-acre Crefeld tract — with “the Paper Mill with all and singular the Improvements, Tools, Iron Potts and every other thing whatsoever belonging to the Paper Making Trade,” and the dwelling house besides — to four men: Abraham Tunis, William Streeper, Claus Ruttinghuysen, and John Gorgas. The price was £145. It is the mill’s birth certificate and its fullest description in a single document: a working paper mill, sold as a going concern with its tools and iron pots, three years after it was built.
The quiet years
After that sale, this seat goes quiet. No operator of the Crefeld mill is named in anything read after 1713. John Gorgas, one of the four buyers, died in 1741, and his will — read in the original — names no paper mill at all. (A will index made in 1900 styles Gorgas a “skin dresser” and names his executor as William Rittenhouse; the will itself names William Kettenhousen. The index is fallible; the original controls.) One claim tries to carry the seat forward: the family historian La Munyan says DeWees’s son Henry afterwards owned the 1710 mill. The claim rests on a map said to have been made in 1746, marking “Hy. Dewees’ Paper Mill” on the seat — Jones, writing in 1896, is the claim’s printed root. The map itself has never been identified. The claim is printed here as a claim, not as a link in the chain.
The second seat and the water rule
DeWees himself did not leave the creek. On March 26, 1729, he bought from the Papen heirs another Crefeld place — 93 acres and a grist mill — and on February 2, 1730, he and Henry Antes put their bargain into an indenture. The grist mill, with two pair of stones and two bolting mills, was built at their joint cost; the dam and the digging of the race were shared; the paper mill’s gears were at DeWees’s own charge; Antes took a half interest in the grist mill. And the deed lays down the water rule that governed the whole arrangement: the paper mill was to be served only by the overplus of water, when the grist mills were supplied. In a dry season, paper waited for flour. It is the earliest surviving operating agreement for a Wissahickon paper mill, and it survives because two partners put their bargain in a deed. La Munyan, writing in 1905, places this second tract at the site of the Convent and Academy of St. Joseph — a locator of 1905, printed as such and not verified here as a modern fact.
The asses-skin mill
One more paper mill hangs over this story, and it will not settle into place. Isaiah Thomas, in his History of Printing in America (1810), preserved the recollection of the aged papermaker John Brighter: a De Wees and Gorgas mill on the Wissahickon, in 1728, making imitation asses-skin paper for memorandum books — paper “made out of rotten stone,” cleansed, Brighter said, by throwing it in the fire for a short time. Weeks, writing in 1916, took the product to be asbestos paper. Whether that 1728 mill was a second seat, a rebuild of the 1710 mill, or the 1729–30 seat misdated in an old man’s memory is unsettled, and it is left unsettled here. Thomas’s own index garbles the partner’s name as “Gorgas, George.”
The junior’s mill
A last name in the cluster belongs to the next generation, and the record will not let it be given to the elder DeWees. The Pennsylvania Gazette of October 4, 1739, carried a stray-horse notice naming a paper mill of “William Dewees, jun.” in Cresheim Township. The junior was a tenant on Edward Farmer’s land in Whitemarsh in the Farmer advertisements of 1738. Whether the 1739 mill was the junior’s own or the elder’s seat loosely styled, the record does not say — the attribution is open, and the 1739 mill is not entered here as the elder’s.
The will, and the end
William DeWees made his will on November 22, 1744; it was proved July 13, 1745. The man the sources credit with building America’s second paper mill left a will that names no paper mill: his son Garrett received the dwelling house, the grist mill, the land, and all the personal estate. The paper trade had passed out of his hands, or out of his estate’s paperwork, long before. DeWees died on March 3, 1745 — that date rests on La Munyan alone — and he lies in the Concord, or Upper, Burying Ground in Germantown.
How the Crefeld mill ended, no record read here tells. No fire, no flood, no later sale, no demolition. After the deed of 1713, the seat’s paper history runs on through the second seat and Brighter’s 1728 testimony, and then the records fall silent. Gibson, in her Chestnut Hill chapter, could still point to where the family works had stood — “a short distance from the road on each side where it crosses the Wissahickon near Northwestern Avenue, were the paper and grist mills of the Dewees family” — but the mills themselves were long gone, and what remains of the Crefeld paper mill is a deed, a water rule, a £5 loan, and an old elm that Daly saw in 1922.
William DeWees and John Gorgas both have their own full stories among this site’s Historical Figures.
Timeline
| 1689/90 | William DeWees comes to Germantown with his brother-in-law Nicholas Rittenhouse |
| 1704 | William DeWees is sheriff of Germantown |
| 1710 | DeWees builds the paper mill at Crefeld, on the tract in Germantown Township |
| 1710 | December: Isaac Van Vlecq lends “Willem DeWees” £5 light money, repayable May 1711; £2 7s is repaid |
| 1713 | December 15: DeWees sells the 100-acre Crefeld tract, with the paper mill, its tools and iron pots, and the dwelling house, to Abraham Tunis, William Streeper, Claus Ruttinghuysen, and John Gorgas, for £145 |
| 1728 | A De Wees and Gorgas mill on the Wissahickon is making imitation asses-skin paper, per John Brighter’s recollection printed by Isaiah Thomas in 1810; which seat this was is unsettled |
| 1729 | March 26: DeWees buys from the Papen heirs a Crefeld place of 93 acres with a grist mill |
| 1730 | February 2: the indenture with Henry Antes — the grist mill at joint cost, and the paper mill to take only the overplus of water after the grist mills are supplied |
| 1739 | October 4: a Pennsylvania Gazette stray-horse notice names a paper mill of “William Dewees, jun.” in Cresheim Township; the attribution is open |
| 1741 | John Gorgas dies; his will names no paper mill |
| 1744 | November 22: William DeWees makes his will; it names no paper mill |
| 1745 | March 3: William DeWees dies (date from La Munyan alone); his will is proved July 13 |
| 1746 | A map of this year, per Jones (1896), marks “Hy. Dewees’ Paper Mill” on the Crefeld seat; the map is unidentified and the claim built on it is unproven |
