Catharine Sands's tie to the Wissahickon is a household and a listing. The Indian Rock hotels stood on Wissahickon Creek in Philadelphia — the first on the drive north of Rex Avenue Bridge, inside what is now Wissahickon Valley Park, the second at Monastery Avenue and the drive, just outside the park's first boundary. Her husband, Reuben Sands, kept the first house, and for fifty years the censuses place her inside its working household on the creek. In 1887, three years a widow, she held a hotel of the Indian Rock name in her own name, her youngest son clerking in it — and her own will papers place that last stand at Monastery Avenue, at the park's edge, where she died at the hotel that November. A modern account gives her the second hotel's founding and a keeping that ran to 1916; the records give her something smaller, stranger, and provable, and this account prints the records. One plain word about her name before anything else: the records of her lifetime read for this account spell it Catharine — the marriage register of 1836 and both directories of 1887. Her death certificate writes "Catherine," and she is found under both spellings here so searchers find her either way. Where the record stops, this account stops with it.
A bride at St Michael's
She was born Catharine Ketz in Philadelphia, daughter of Jacob Ketz and Anna Maria — the parents are named in the index of her marriage record, the only record that preserves her maiden name at all. No baptism for her was read, and her birth year moves from record to record: her death certificate says she was 65 when she died in November 1887, which makes her born in 1822, and the census of 1860 agrees; the census of 1870 makes her born about 1820; the census of 1880, about 1817. All of them stand. On November 30, 1836, at St Michael's in Germantown, she married Reuben Sands, a young public-house keeper of about twenty whose own parents the register's index names as Ezra Sands and Eleonor. On the death certificate's arithmetic she was a bride of fourteen; on the 1880 census's, about nineteen. The register gives no ages, and the record does not narrow it further. She was, on any reading, very young, and the marriage lasted forty-seven years.
The roadhouse years
Reuben Sands kept houses in the Chestnut Hill and Germantown neighbourhood before the creek. In 1863 the Press names "the public house of Reuben Sands, at Chestnut Hill" in a theft case, and Hotchkin's history of the neighbourhood, read in full, fixes the spot: on Springfield Avenue, where the Park Hotel rose in 1863, "there had been a small hotel at this point kept by Reuben Sands, of Indian Rock, now deceased." McElroy's directory of 1866 puts his hotel on Germantown Avenue; Gopsill's of 1871 gives him his first creek listing — liquors, on the Wissahickon road near Wise's Mill Road.
The Library Company of Philadelphia's catalogue dates the first Indian Rock Hotel itself to 1848 — opened by Reuben Sands north of Rex Avenue Bridge, sold to the Fairmount Park Commission in 1872, the building afterward a park police headquarters. That date stands at the catalogue's grade: the directories show no Sands hotel on the creek before 1865, and the catalogue's own claimed source, Bicknell's 1908 paper on the Wissahickon, was read in full and does not contain the date — or a wife, or a second hotel. What Bicknell does contain is the keeper's own mark on the valley. The board figure of Tedyuscung at Indian Rock, set up in 1854 by Joseph Middleton, wore out, and "Rube Sands had a larger and more artistic image made and put in its place, which remained until the present statue was erected." And Bicknell remembered, writing in 1906, that "until recently, there might have been seen the foundations of Rube Sands' Indian Rock Hotel, which was for many years the most famous road house around Philadelphia."
The sale of 1872 is complicated by the park's own paper: the Fairmount Park Commission's report for 1878 lists the Indian Rock Hotel still open inside the park, one of seven refreshment places, and an 1884 survey of the creek counts an Indian Rock hotel among the four hotels on the drive without saying which house. Whether the Sandses stayed on under the park or left in 1872, no record read says.
The censuses give the inside of the house. In 1860: Reuben, 43, "Cathe," 38, and five children. In 1870: Reuben, 52, Cathie, 50, four sons at home, and a servant named Shepherd, 35, born in Virginia. In 1880, the fullest page: Reuben Sands, 63, "Hotel Keeper"; Catharine Sands, 63, his wife, "Keeping House"; their son Harry, 21, a clerk; and the staff of the roadhouse living in the household — an Irish bartender, two hostlers, two waiters, and a girl of fourteen at school. Eleven people under the hotel's roof, and the woman at its head entered with the period's own word for her work: keeping house. The sporting paper that noticed Reuben's death called the house "a favorite resort of the lovers of good cheer" and him its proprietor "for many years." That was the world Catharine Ketz married into at St Michael's, and it was her home for the rest of her life.
Six children
Constantine, the eldest, died in October 1874, aged 34 — on October 5 by his death certificate's index, on October 6 by his tombstone as transcribed in 1936; both dates stand — and was buried at the Chestnut Hill Baptist Church; he left a wife, Carrie, and at least one daughter. Wilfred died in August 1876, aged 25, a married man — his tombstone in the same transcription dates it August 14 — and was buried in the same churchyard two years after his brother. Two grown sons gone in two years, while the hotel traded on. They were not the first: Howard, 17 in 1860, has a stone in that yard in the 1936 transcription — Howard M. Sands, of the Anderson Cavalry, died at Louisville, Kentucky, on July 16, 1863, "from disease contracted in the service." The volume warns some stones were already hard to read, and no service record for him was read; the stone's account stands at the transcription's grade. Victoria, 19 in 1860, leaves the household by 1870 — and her mother's will finds her: "my daughter Victoria L. Streeper," executrix of the estate in December 1887. Her married name is Streeper. A Find a Grave lead gives her birth as October 28, 1837, against the census's age of 19 — born about 1840–41; both stand, neither chosen. Her death was not found in any record read. Reuben Milton, her mother's executor in 1887, died on September 12, 1899, on a death index entry matched to him by name and age, and lies at Ivy Hill. Harry Jefferson, the youngest, was born on July 4, 1860; the 1870 census enters him as "Henry J.," a name form that stands unreconciled against his birth record, the 1880 census and his mother's will, which names him "my Son, Harry Jefferson Sands." His birth record names his mother only as "Catharine," no surname — as does every record of her children. Not one of them gives her maiden name. Only the Germantown register of 1836 does: Ketz.
Widowed
Reuben Sands died in August 1884, and the day itself is doubled in the record. His death certificate gives August 19, 1884, aged 68, and his burial on August 24 at the Baptist Church, Chestnut Hill; his death notice in an unnamed newspaper agrees — "On the 19th inst., after a lingering illness" — and a news item calls him "for eighteen years keeper of the Indian Rock Hotel." The New York Clipper of August 30 gives August 20, "in the sixty-ninth year of his age" — the age in exact agreement with the certificate, the day off by one. Both stand; the certificate governs. Catharine was about sixty-two. The widowhood is not the silence it once seemed: on September 3, 1884, fifteen days after his death, she made her will — "I, Catharine Sands (widow of Reuben Sands)" — leaving the hotel furniture and the business at the Indian Rock to Victoria and Reuben Milton "until they shall be required to vacate the same by the Park Commissioners," with a third of the profits to Harry Jefferson for life if he conducted himself "in a proper quiet and peaceful manner" and did not interfere. Between that will and her codicil of October 1887, no record read names her daily life — the 1890 census does not survive to catch her, and no directory line, newspaper item, or church record read fills the three years between her two documents. That silence is printed as silence. Reuben's own probate was searched for and not found; hers survives entire.
1887: her name in the directory
Then, in 1887, two Philadelphia directories name her in her own right. Gopsill's, in its hotel list: "Indian Rock, Catharine Sands, C Hill" — Chestnut Hill. Boyd's: "Catharine, hotel, C Hill," with a Harry J. Sands clerking at the same hotel. The clerk is her youngest son: the 1880 census puts Harry Sands in his father's household as "Son," a clerk, and his 1860 birth record makes him Reuben and Catharine's child. A widow of about sixty-five, keeping a hotel of the famous name in her own name, her youngest boy behind the desk.
By 1893 she is gone from Boyd's. That absence once looked like a keeper leaving the trade. It is explained now: the listing of 1887 was her last year, not her first. Which house she kept, the directories do not say beyond "Chestnut Hill" — but her own papers do. On October 12, 1887, she added a codicil to her will. The house the will was written for, "within the limits of the Park and known as the 'Indian Rock Hotel'," she records, "has been torn down and removed." The business now stood "at my present Stand, situate at the Corner of Monastery Avenue, and Magdalena Street, near the Wissahickon Drive and also known as the Indian Rock Hotel in the 21st Ward of the City of Philadelphia" — and there her son and daughter were to have "the power right and privilege of conducting the Hotel Business." When the stand opened, no record read says. The directories' "Chestnut Hill" and the codicil's Monastery Avenue stand side by side, unreconciled; her death certificate gives her residence as Chestnut Hill, in the 22nd Ward, and a keeper may live in one ward and trade in the next. No record read describes either building. Whether she held a tavern licence in her own name, the Quarter Sessions petitions that would prove it sit at the City Archives, not read; they stand in the Still to check list, and nothing here rests on them.
The death certificate
Her death certificate — read in its image, and indexed twice, once as "Catherine Sands" and once as "Cathn. Sands" — records: Catherine Sands, 65 years old, a widow, born in Philadelphia; died November 21, 1887, of consumption; her home Chestnut Hill, in the 22nd Ward; buried November 25, 1887, at the Chestnut Hill Baptist Church. The certificate spells her Catherine; the register, the directories and every handwritten line of her probate packet spell her Catharine, and Catharine she is in this account, on the earlier records' authority.
Her executors' petition, sworn December 8, 1887, gives the place and the hour the certificate leaves out: she died at "The Hotel Corner of Monastery Avenue & Wissahickon Drive," on Monday, November 21, 1887, at half past nine in the evening — at her hotel, six weeks after the codicil. Her death notice, in an unnamed newspaper, sends the funeral "from her late residence, Monastery avenue and Wissahickon drive." The inventory of her goods, sworn December 12, totals $1,088.50 and reads like the house itself: bar room, a stock of wines and liquors, three parlours — one with a piano — four chambers, two horses, a cow, chickens, a carriage and a sleigh.
She went into the same churchyard as her husband, buried there in August 1884, and her sons Constantine and Wilfred, buried there in 1874 and 1876. The churchyard's inscriptions, copied in 1936, hold stones for the three dead sons and none for her or for Reuben — the transcription notes removals to Hillside Cemetery — so the burials rest on the certificates, and both facts stand. No obituary for her was found in the newspapers read. The directory canvass of 1887 is the last sight of her alive, and it is in her own name.
The second hotel, and the story that grew
The second Indian Rock Hotel stood at Monastery Avenue and the drive, just outside the park's first boundary — placed there, in the usual telling, to stand beyond the park's liquor ban. The Friends of the Wissahickon's "Roadhouses of the Wissahickon" tells its founding in one sentence:
"The Second Indian Rock Hotel was opened by Catherine Sands, the widow of Reuben Sands. It was constructed at Monastery Avenue & the Wissahickon turnpike after 1887, right on the edge of the park where the liquor prohibition didn't apply. It operated until 1916 when it was also taken by the park as the park boundaries were expanded."
The page cites no source for the sentence. Its first-hotel dates — built "after the Civil War," closed in 1887 — conflict with the Library Company's 1848 and 1872 and with the Park Commission's own 1878 listing. And the sentence now fails on a fact it cannot survive: the woman it names died on November 21, 1887. She did not operate anything until 1916. The keeping is refuted outright, and the founding-after-1887 fails beside it — her codicil already stands at the house in October 1887. And yet the avenue is real, and it is hers: not on the modern page's authority, but on her own probate papers, which put her "present Stand... also known as the Indian Rock Hotel" at Monastery Avenue and record her death at the hotel there. An earlier account in this series held that no record puts a Sands hotel on Monastery Avenue at any date; that position was correct on the record then held and is withdrawn on hers. What she founded there, and when, the records do not say — Daly gives the building to Reuben, the captions give it to the early 1870s, and her codicil gives only the fact of the stand in 1887. The founding and the taking stand or fall on the records, and on the records they fall into conflict:
- Daly, 1922. T. A. Daly's The Wissahickon, read in full, gives the second house to Reuben: "The Park Commission removed the original tavern, and Sands erected another on Monastery Avenue, just beyond the park limits. But that, too, has passed." A printed source, forty years after the fact, naming no wife — and his own source for the sentence is unverified, since Bicknell, whom he names among his sources, does not contain it.
- The Library Company. Its caption for the house: "built in the early 1870s following the purchase of the original building by the Fairmount Park Commission, procured by Charles Weingartner in 1894… razed prior to 1916." The same text stands word for word on its postcard record — one cataloguing text, counted once. Its first-hotel records add that "Sands opened a second Indian Rock Hotel at a nearby location," no first name, no wife.
- The Chestnut Hill Conservancy, cataloguing its 1895 photograph of the house: "It opened in 1870 and was a favorite stopping place for coaching and sleighing parties."
After her death the house's documented keepers are not Sandses — though who held it between November 1887 and 1892 no record read shows: her estate still held "the hotel and restaurant at Indian Rock" into an Orphans' Court fight, and two index-only directory lines, leads only, put her son Reuben M. at "Hotel, Monastery Av, Roxb" in 1891. Barbara Tresch was proprietress by October 1892 — the Builders' Guide reported her twelve-room annex that month; its story says two storeys, the permit says three, and both stand — and the Bromley atlases of 1895 and 1910 print her name as the house's owner. Charles Weingartner kept it in 1894 and again in 1899; the 1896 directory, read in its pages, gives "Weingartner Chas, hotel, Wiss drive c Monastery av, Roxb," and a city ordinance of March 16, 1896 orders a drain "across Monastery avenue, above the Indian Rock hotel, in the Twenty-first Ward." On June 26, 1901, Tresch sold the property to Katharine Lowa for $26,500, and the Lowas kept it past 1911 — against which stands the 1908 directory's "Weingartner Chas, prop Indian Rock Hotel," read in its pages; proprietor and owner may be different roles, and the two lines stand unresolved. In 1894 the house was certainly trading: a Manufacturers' Club party "proceeded by coach up the Wissahickon to Indian Rock Hotel, where dinner was served" — Factory magazine names the dinner, not the keeper.
And the end? The park's Descriptive Souvenir names the hotel at the Monastery Avenue spring in 1915 and omits it in 1917. The Evening Public Ledger of 1908–1922 carries no taking, no demolition, no sale. But the Forecast of February 25, 1915 reports the purchase outright: the Indian Rock Hotel, "Monastery avenue and Wissahickon drive," "has been purchased by the Fairmount Park Commission," offered at $25,000 by a broker, William Macdonald, "bought subject to the approval of Common Pleas Court" — and "Several years ago Dr. William J. O'Brien, 1763 Frankford avenue, purchased the hotel and the land surrounding it." A later column (1933) puts a Board of Viewers on the damage claims in 1916 and the property in O'Brien's hands. So the park bought it in 1915, out of O'Brien's ownership; the final award — who was paid, and how much — was not found. The files that could settle it exist — the Park Commission's Land Purchases and Damages committee kept minutes and correspondence on specific acquisitions, and its archive's catalogue names the Indian Rock Hotel among them; a plan of property condemned by the Commission's resolution of May 10, 1916 is catalogued in the park's maps collection, its property unnamed in the catalogue line — and those files sit on paper, not read, with no claim in this account resting on them. The gap is printed as plainly as the facts: the settling record exists, where it sits is known, and it has not been read.
The claims that don't hold
Three claims fail on the records, and they are stopped here. That Catherine Sands opened the second hotel after 1887 and ran it until 1916 — refuted as to her by her death certificate, contradicted as to the keeping by the Tresch, Weingartner and Lowa records, and contradicted as to the opening by her own codicil, which stands at the house in October 1887; no source is cited for the claim anywhere. That Bicknell dated the first hotel to 1848 — his paper, read in full, contains no date for it, no wife, and no second hotel; the 1848 belongs to the Library Company's catalogue alone. And that she was a Chestnut Hill keeper only, with no Sands hotel on Monastery Avenue at any date — her codicil, her executors' petition and her funeral notice place her hotel and her death at Monastery Avenue; the avenue's other Sands in print, a "Mrs. George Sands" of 1917 and 1918, is thirty years after her death, a stranger left unmerged. One gentler convergence stays open: Hotchkin's history describes a Main Street, Chestnut Hill household of an Ezra Sands whose parents were Ezra Sands Sr. and Eleanor — the names the marriage register gives for Reuben's parents. Kin, very likely; stated by no record read; not merged here.
What the record cannot say is printed with the rest: her exact birthday and baptism (the St Michael's register was read through its index, not in full); where she spent the years between her will of 1884 and her codicil of 1887; when her Monastery Avenue stand opened, and who kept the house between her death and 1892; whether the city licensed her to keep it; her daughter Victoria's death; her husband's probate, searched for and not found; who built the second hotel; and what the park finally paid for its ground, and to whom. No photograph of Catharine Sands is known to exist, and the surviving photographs of the second hotel are not cleared for use, so none is printed here. What remains is the record's own outline, and it needs no help: a Germantown bride of 1836, fifty years in the most famous roadhouse household on the Wissahickon, three sons buried, a widow who papered her own succession and kept the name in her own name with her youngest boy clerking — and gone the same November, at her hotel on Monastery Avenue, twenty-nine years before the story handed her a keeping she never had.
Timeline
| Year | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| About 1822 | Born in Philadelphia, daughter of Jacob Ketz and Anna Maria (her birth year reads 1822, about 1820, and about 1817 across the records) | Death certificate; censuses of 1860, 1870, 1880 |
| 1836 | Marries Reuben Sands, November 30, at St Michael's, Germantown | St Michael's marriage register (index) |
| 1860 | In the 22nd Ward household with Reuben and five children | U.S. Census, 1860 |
| 1863 | Son Howard dies July 16, at Louisville, Kentucky, of disease in service (Anderson Cavalry) | Tombstone transcription, Chestnut Hill Baptist inscriptions (copied 1936) |
| 1863 | Reuben's public house at Chestnut Hill named in a theft case; Hotchkin fixes it on Springfield Avenue | Press, 1863; Hotchkin (1889), p. 401 |
| 1866 | Reuben's hotel listed on Germantown Avenue | McElroy's directory, 1866 |
| 1870 | In the Ward 22 household with four sons and a servant | U.S. Census, 1870 |
| 1871 | Reuben's first creek listing: liquors, Wissahickon road near Wise's Mill Road | Gopsill's directory, 1871 |
| 1872 | The first hotel sold to the Fairmount Park Commission (the Library Company's dating; its claimed source, Bicknell, does not contain the 1848 opening) | Library Company catalogue, P.9731.124, P.9260.69 |
| 1874 | Son Constantine dies — October 5 by his death certificate, October 6 by his tombstone; buried at Chestnut Hill Baptist Church | Death certificate; tombstone transcription (1936) |
| 1876 | Son Wilfred dies August 14 (his tombstone); buried at Chestnut Hill Baptist Church | Tombstone transcription (1936); death certificate |
| 1878 | The Park Commission's report lists the Indian Rock Hotel still open inside the park | Fairmount Park Commission report, 1878 |
| 1880 | The household at full strength: Reuben "Hotel Keeper," Catharine "Keeping House," son Harry clerking, the staff living in | U.S. Census, 1880 |
| 1884 | Reuben dies — August 19 by his certificate, August 20 by the Clipper; buried August 24, Chestnut Hill Baptist Church | Death certificate; New York Clipper, August 30, 1884 |
| 1884 | Her will, September 3: the hotel business to Victoria L. Streeper and Reuben Milton Sands "until they shall be required to vacate the same by the Park Commissioners" | Will, Will Book 136, No. 1320 of 1887 (image read) |
| 1887 | Her hotel listing in her own name: "Indian Rock, Catharine Sands, C Hill"; her son Harry J. clerking | Gopsill's and Boyd's directories, 1887 |
| 1887 | Codicil, October 12: the park-limits hotel "torn down and removed"; the business at her "present Stand," Monastery Avenue & Magdalena Street, "also known as the Indian Rock Hotel" | Codicil (image read) |
| 1887 | Dies November 21, at the hotel, Monastery Avenue & Wissahickon Drive, of consumption; buried November 25, Chestnut Hill Baptist Church | Probate petition; death certificate (image read) |
| 1887 | Probate: petition and oath December 8; inventory filed December 19, total $1,088.50 | Probate packet, No. 1320 of 1887 |
| 1892 | Barbara Tresch, proprietress of the Monastery Avenue house, plans a twelve-room annex | Builders' Guide, October 1892 |
| 1894 | Charles Weingartner keeps the Monastery Avenue house; a Manufacturers' Club dinner is served there | Library Company caption, P.9731.125; Factory, May 23, 1894 |
| 1896 | A city ordinance orders a drain "across Monastery avenue, above the Indian Rock hotel"; Weingartner listed at "Wiss drive c Monastery av" | Philadelphia ordinance, March 16, 1896; city directory, 1896 (page image read) |
| 1899 | Weingartner keeps the house again | Directory record, as carried in the published account of the house |
| 1901 | Tresch sells the Monastery Avenue property to Katharine Lowa, June 26, for $26,500 | The conveyance, as reported from the deed record |
| 1906 | Youngest son Harry dies November 20, at Ocean City, New Jersey; his certificate names his mother "UNKNOWN" | Death certificate |
| 1915 / 1917 | The park's souvenir guide names the Monastery Avenue hotel in 1915, omits it in 1917 | Descriptive Souvenir of Fairmount Park, 1915 and 1917 |
| 1915 | The park's purchase of the hotel property reported: bought from Dr. William J. O'Brien's ownership, offered at $25,000; the damages process runs into 1916; the final award was not found, and the Commission's acquisition file was not read | Forecast, February 25, 1915; Chadwick column, 1933 (later account) |
| 1922 | Daly's The Wissahickon gives the second house's building to Reuben himself | Daly (1922), pp. 62–63 |
