The Thomas Mill stood on Wissahickon Creek at the Thomas Mill Road crossing in Chestnut Hill, inside the city of Philadelphia, well below the county line at Northwestern Avenue. The crossing is still there, and it is famous: the Thomas Mill Road Covered Bridge, the only covered bridge left in Philadelphia. The mill is not there, and it is not famous. Of all the mills in this collection, this one’s file is the thinnest — two surnames and three road names are nearly all the record gives it.
What the record does give, it gives plainly. John T. Daly, writing in 1922, put the whole early history in two sentences: “In 1738 there was a grist mill here, and the road was known as Barge’s Mill Road until 1784 when Thomas bought the plant. In 1859 it was taken over by Charles Megargee who made a paper mill of it.” Frederick Brandt’s 1927 history of the valley confirms the road’s side of the story: Thomas Mill Road has been “so-called since 1784.”
Barge, then Thomas
So the chain, as far as anything read can take it, is this. By 1738 a grist mill stood at the crossing, and the road to it carried the name Barge. Who Barge was, no source read says — the surname is all that survives of him. In 1784 a man surnamed Thomas bought the plant, and the road took his name. Who Thomas was, no source read says either. One caution belongs here: some modern web accounts say the bridge was named for a nearby mill “operated by Thomas Mill” in the early 1800s — a man actually named Thomas Mill. No source from the period names any such man. Daly and Brandt give a buyer surnamed Thomas in 1784, and that is what is printed here; the web version is noted only to be set aside.
Spruce Mill
The mill’s third name is the strangest. Charles Ellet’s map of Philadelphia County, drawn in 1843, labels the seat “Spruce Mill” and its lane “Spruce Mill Lane.” Whether “Spruce” was a man’s name, a tree, or something else entirely, no source read explains. The tangle matters for a practical reason: a mill that answers to three names can hide inside other mills’ records, and any future find for a “Spruce Mill” on this creek belongs to this seat first.
Seventy-five silent years
Between 1784 and 1859 — seventy-five years — no operator of this mill is named in anything read. That gap is printed here, not filled. What the mill ground, who ran it, and how it fared through those decades is simply not in the record this account rests on.
Megargee’s paper mill
In 1859 the silence ends. Charles Megargee, whose paper mills stood a short distance downstream on Wise’s Mill Road, took over the seat and converted it from a grist mill to a paper mill. That is all the record says about the working mill in its paper years: no count of its vats, no workforce, no output, and no name its paper sold under. Megargee’s firm sold its paper through its Wissahickon Paper Mills, with a warehouse at 30 South Sixth Street — that was the firm’s documented pattern at its home seat on Wise’s Mill Road, and it is printed here as the firm’s pattern, not as a record of this mill.
The end
The end is as thin as the beginning. No demolition date for this mill was found in anything read. The seat lay inside the ground the Fairmount Park Commission took over beginning in 1868, and Louise Gibson’s general sentence for the mills the city took — “Once taken over by the city, the buildings were torn down or became derelict” — is as close as the record comes to this mill’s end. Whether Megargee’s paper mill here outlasted the 1883–84 end of his home seat downstream, no source read says.
The crossing that survives
What survives is the crossing. The covered bridge was built in 1855 — a truss bridge of 86.5 feet. The National Register record, which this account follows, calls it a Howe truss; some modern tourism pages say Burr-arch, and the disagreement is printed rather than resolved. The bridge was rebuilt by the WPA in 1939, a detail carried from the Waymarking record. It was listed on the National Register on December 1, 1980. But the bridge is the seat’s landmark, not the mill, and this account keeps the two apart.
Brandt left the seat one last concrete detail, and it can still be seen: “Thomas Mill Road, on the left, does not square with the road at the bridge.” The road and its bridge were never aligned — the crossing grew rather than being laid out, and the road, now parts of West Chestnut Hill Avenue and West Highland Avenue, kept the Thomas name from 1784 onward. The road remembered the man longer than any record did. Of the mill itself — its stones, its paper, its people — the record kept almost nothing, and what it kept is what you have just read.
Timeline
| 1738 | A grist mill stands at the Thomas Mill Road crossing of Wissahickon Creek; the road is known as Barge’s Mill Road (Daly). |
| 1784 | A buyer surnamed Thomas purchases the plant; the road takes his name and is “so-called” from this year (Daly; Brandt). |
| 1843 | Ellet’s map of Philadelphia County labels the seat “Spruce Mill” and its lane “Spruce Mill Lane.” |
| 1855 | The covered bridge is built at the crossing: a truss bridge of 86.5 feet (National Register data). |
| 1859 | Charles Megargee takes over the seat and converts it to a paper mill (Daly). |
| 1868 | The Fairmount Park Commission begins taking over the valley; this seat lies inside the taken ground. |
| 1939 | The covered bridge is rebuilt by the WPA (per the Waymarking record). |
| 1980 | The Thomas Mill Road Covered Bridge is listed on the National Register, December 1 (NR 80003621). |
