Above Valley Green · on Wissahickon Creek at Wise’s Mill Road · 1731–1884

Megargee’s Paper Mills — Wise’s Mill RoadMegargee's Paper Mills

Wise’s Mill Road — the last working mills on the creek

A Megargee mill building at the water's edge above the dam, Bartlett and French stereograph
A Megargee mill building at the water’s edge above the dam — a Bartlett & French stereograph titled “Wissahickon Creek near Megargee’s Mills.” New York Public Library, Robert N. Dennis Collection of Stereoscopic Views, via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

Every mill on Wissahickon Creek is gone, and this one went last. The paper mills at the foot of Wise’s Mill Road, just above Valley Green, were the final working mills on the creek — the last of the Wissahickon mills, as Frederick Brandt titled his chapter about them in 1927. The buildings were taken down in 1884. The dam that powered them is still there.

The seat and the dam

The seat stands on the main stem of Wissahickon Creek, inside the city of Philadelphia, about a mile and a half below the Montgomery County line at Northwestern Avenue. It has its own small tributary: the Philadelphia Water Department’s fish-passage study places the dam “just upstream of the confluence of Wissahickon Creek and Wises Mill Run,” and adds the sentence this whole story hangs on — “the dam still remains.”

The road and the name

Even the road is part of the record. Brandt dates Wise’s Mill Road to 1738, and a Library Company of Philadelphia collection note gives the road’s older name as “Weiss’s (Wise) Mill Road” — the name is German before it is English. One caution belongs here at the start: no “Wise family” running a mill at this seat was verified in anything read. “Wise’s” is the road’s name, and this account prints it as a name, not as a family.

1731 or 1737

The Library Company of Philadelphia’s catalog record for the firm’s lithograph says the paper mill here was “originally built for William Dewees in 1731.” That makes this a second, later DeWees seat — not the Crefeld paper mill of 1710 — and the two are kept separate in this collection. Against the date stands a second one: notes in the Affel Canoe Club study cite Contosta and Franklin’s Metropolitan Paradise for a drawing of “the Upper Magargee Mill, built in 1737.” 1731 and 1737 are both printed here; neither is preferred. Brandt adds that a grist mill stood at the seat as early as 1738, but that paper was then manufactured on this spot “for nearly 150 years.”

The century gap

Then the record goes quiet for a century. Between the grist mill of 1738 and 1844, no operator of this seat is named in anything read. That gap is printed, not filled.

Charles Magarge

In 1844 Charles Magarge rented the mill. He was president of the Bank of Germantown, according to the Library Company record, and in 1853 he bought the works outright and expanded them to house a Fourdrinier paper machine. The firm’s own name for the place was the Wissahickon Paper Mills, and its paper was the celebrated “Wissahickon Paper.” Brandt explains the fame: “Here still flows the spring-filtered water whose purity made possible the whiteness and quality of the celebrated ’Wissahickon Paper.’” The power was the creek itself, held back by the dam above Wises Mill Run.

The works at their height survive in a picture. William E. Winner’s oil painting “Magarge Paper Mill,” from about 1858, shows “the main building, boiler house, machine room, and chimney” of the expanded mill; a lithograph by A. Frey, made after the painting, carried the image as the firm’s advertisement, with the firm’s city warehouse named in its title at 30 South Sixth Street. The Hexamer insurance survey drew the mills in 1866 — plate 128, “Charles Magarge’s Wissahickon Paper Mills.” The Library Company catalog makes one more claim for this mill: “It was the first mill to use wood pulp to make paper.” That sentence is printed here in the catalog’s own words, as the catalog’s claim, and at no higher grade — this account does not adopt it as a finding. The name itself comes down spelled three ways — Magarge in Brandt, the survey, and the Library Company record; Megargee in Daly; Magargee in the Paper Trade Journal and the later surveys — one firm under three spellings, all printed as found.

Hexamer insurance survey plate 128 of 1866, Charles Magarge's Wissahickon Paper Mills
The mills drawn for their fire-insurance survey: Hexamer’s plate 128 of 1866, “Charles Magarge’s Wissahickon Paper Mills” — the buildings as the surveyor drew them. A survey drawing, not a photograph. Via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

Three mills on the Wissahickon

Magarge’s reach ran beyond this one seat. In 1859 the same Charles Megargee took over the Thomas Mill seat upstream and made a paper mill of it, so at its height the firm held paper mills at two Wissahickon seats. And when the Paper Trade Journal reported the firm’s failure in October 1877, it said the firm owned and operated “three upon the Wissahickon” — the Upper and Lower mills here, and a third, leased mill the Journal calls Hanwell. Hanwell is not located anywhere in what was read: a Hexamer plate, volume 4, plate 272, names Edward Magarge as the client of a “Hanwell Paper Mill,” and that is all this account prints of it. The same failure report added that the Park Commission had recently purchased the ground of one of the three, “the owner, however, being granted the privilege of operating it for ten years longer.”

The failure

The failure itself is documented in the Journal’s own columns, and it reads like a slow collapse. The firm suspended in October 1877 — Magarge’s sickness first, and then a mortgage judgment (the Godey judgment) broke his credit. A creditors’ meeting put the firm’s indebtedness at $200,200 against assets of $175,600. On November 3, 1877, the creditors adopted a composition of fifty cents on the dollar, and by December 8 the settlement was being consummated. The firm traded on: its advertisements — “Wissahickon and Hanwell Mills Papers,” listing 30, 32 and 34 South Sixth Street — run through 1878 and into April 1879. For the leased Hanwell mill, the Journal of July 13, 1878 carried both a news item and Magarge’s own advertisement: the mill still running, his lease from the Commissioners of Fairmount Park expiring July 16, 1878, and the plant offered at private sale for $15,000 — one Fourdrinier machine, four engines, a rag boiler and cutter, turning out 85,000 to 100,000 pounds a month of fine book paper. Two things often carried with this story were not found in the twenty-six Journal issues searched, and they are printed at a lower grade for that reason: that Alexander Balfour was co-lessee of the third mill in 1878, and that he purchased Megargee’s Wissahickon interest in 1879. What the Journal does state, in its own words, is the end. On April 28, 1883: “Alex. Balfour is moving the machinery from the Wissahickon Mill to his new mill at Philadelphia.”

The end, in two steps

So the last mill ended in two steps, and the sources keep them separate. The work ended in 1883 — the Water Department study states it flatly: “Magarge Mill closed in 1883, but the dam still remains.” The buildings stood one year more. John T. Daly, writing in 1922, gave this seat its distinction: when the park commissioners cleared the valley after 1873, “All these establishments, with the single exception of the Megargee Paper Mill near Chestnut Hill (which was allowed to stand until 1884) were immediately torn down.” Brandt’s word for 1884 is “removed.” The mill’s office survived the demolition in a new job — Brandt, on the ground in 1927, found it “still in use as a Park Guard House.” And the demolished mills had a second life of their own: the Lotus Inn, built in the 1880s at the foot of Shur’s Lane, “was constructed… using materials from the demolished Megargee Mills,” and served catfish and waffles there until the park expansion closed it in 1916.

Detail of Cresson's 1869 survey of Wissahickon Creek showing Magargee's Mill at Wise's Mill Lane
The seat on Cresson’s survey of Wissahickon Creek, drawn in 1869 for the park commissioners: “MAGARGEE’S MILL” lettered at Wise’s Mill Lane, the buildings and the race drawn beside the creek. A survey drawing of the seat, not a photograph. From the printed survey, New York Public Library. Public domain.

The fountain

The last miller left his name somewhere no mill history mentions. Half a mile beyond Valley Green stands the Pro Bono Publico fountain of 1854 — the first drinking fountain in Philadelphia, according to Daly. It was “the joint gift of John Cook, by whom it was erected, and Charles Megargee, owner of the land, whose famous paper mill, in a nearby meadow, was the last industrial establishment left standing along the Wissahickon.” Brandt adds the fountain’s inscriptions: “Pro bono publico” — “Esto perpetua.” For the public good; may it last forever.

The family after the creek

The family outlasted the creek. The Hexamer indexes carry the firm’s later mills — the Dove Mills (Magargee Brothers, 1882; Estate of Theodor Megargee, 1894) and the Spring Lawn Mill of the Megargee Paper Mills (1894). The Wissahickon closure of 1883–84 did not end the family in paper; it ended paper on this creek.

The dam still remains

What is left at the seat is the dam, and the dam is now a problem in its own record. The Water Department study records that Tropical Storm Floyd in 1999 “severely damaged” it and “breached the right side,” so the creek now flows around the dam’s downstream right side, wearing the bank away toward Forbidden Drive; the study recommended the dam’s removal or modification, and its language calls the broken dam a major safety hazard. Brandt, seventy years earlier, had seen it gentler: “Battered and broken, the old dam beyond the Guard House marks the departed glory of the missing mill.” The dam still remains.

Timeline

1731The paper mill at the foot of Wise’s Mill Road is built for William Dewees (Library Company of Philadelphia catalog record; a second source dates the Upper Magargee Mill to 1737 — see 1737).
1737Alternative building date for the Upper Magargee Mill, from a drawing caption in Contosta & Franklin, Metropolitan Paradise, as cited in the Affel Canoe Club study’s notes (citation grade).
1738Wise’s Mill Road is dated to this year, and a grist mill stands at the seat (Brandt).
1844Charles Magarge rents the mill (Library Company record).
1853Magarge purchases the mill and expands it to house a Fourdrinier paper machine (Library Company record).
1854The Pro Bono Publico fountain is erected, the joint gift of John Cook and Charles Megargee (Daly).
1858William E. Winner paints “Magarge Paper Mill,” showing the expanded works; A. Frey’s lithograph after it advertises the firm (about this year; Library Company record).
1859Charles Megargee takes over the Thomas Mill seat and makes a paper mill of it — the firm’s second Wissahickon seat (Daly).
1866Hexamer’s insurance survey of the mills, volume 2, plate 128: “Charles Magarge’s Wissahickon Paper Mills.”
1877The firm suspends in October (Magarge’s sickness, then the Godey mortgage judgment); the Paper Trade Journal reports it owned and operated “three upon the Wissahickon” (October 20). A creditors’ meeting sets the indebtedness at $200,200 against assets of $175,600 (October 27). A composition of fifty cents on the dollar is adopted (November 3), and the settlement is being consummated by December 8.
1878The leased Hanwell mill is offered at private sale, asking $15,000, its Fairmount Park lease expiring July 16 (Paper Trade Journal, July 13). The firm’s “Wissahickon and Hanwell Mills Papers” advertisements run through this year and into April 1879.
1882The Hexamer indexes carry the Dove Mills for Magargee Brothers — the family’s paper-making continues off the creek.
1883Alexander Balfour moves the machinery out of the Wissahickon Mill (Paper Trade Journal, April 28). The mill closes (Philadelphia Water Department study).
1884The mill buildings are removed — the single exception allowed to stand until this year when the park commissioners cleared the valley (Daly; Brandt). The mill office survives as a Park Guard House.
1880sThe Lotus Inn is built at the foot of Shur’s Lane using materials from the demolished Megargee Mills (Friends of the Wissahickon).
1894The Hexamer indexes carry the Dove Mills for the Estate of Theodor Megargee, and the Spring Lawn Mill for the Megargee Paper Mills.
1916The Lotus Inn closes under the park expansion (Friends of the Wissahickon).
1927Brandt records the old mill office in use as a Park Guard House and the dam standing “battered and broken.”
1999Tropical Storm Floyd severely damages the dam and breaches its right side (Philadelphia Water Department study).

The Cellar

Sources

  1. Library Company of Philadelphia, catalog record, “Wissahiccon Paper Mills. Warehouse, 30 South Sixth Street, Charles Magarge & Co.” (lithograph by A. Frey, c. 1858, after Winner’s painting) — read. The mill built for William Dewees in 1731; rented by Charles Magarge in 1844; purchased by him in 1853; expanded for a Fourdrinier machine; the wood-pulp claim, in the catalog’s own words; the painting’s contents and location.
  2. Brandt, Frederick (1927), The Wissahickon Valley within the City of Philadelphia — read. The “Last of the Wissahickon Mills” chapter and the Guard House passage: the 1738 grist mill and nearly 150 years of paper; Wise’s Mill Road dated 1738; the spring-filtered water and the celebrated “Wissahickon Paper”; the office in use as a Park Guard House; the mills “removed in 1884”; the fountain’s builder and inscriptions.
  3. Daly, John T. (1922), The Wissahickon, pp. 39–40 and p. 61 — read. The Megargee Paper Mill the single exception allowed to stand until 1884; the Pro Bono Publico fountain as the joint gift of John Cook and Charles Megargee, and the first drinking fountain in Philadelphia.
  4. Philadelphia Water Department / Philadelphia Watersheds, Wissahickon Creek Fish Passage study — the Magarge Dam section, read. The dam just upstream of the Wises Mill Run confluence; the mill closed in 1883; the dam still remains; the 1999 Tropical Storm Floyd breach and the recommendation of removal or modification.
  5. Paper Trade Journal (Internet Archive per-issue full texts) — verified against the Journal’s own text, twenty-six issues searched, October 1877–April 1883. The failure report and “three upon the Wissahickon” (October 20, 1877); the creditors’ meeting and the $200,200 indebtedness (October 27, 1877); the fifty-cent composition adopted (November 3, 1877); the settlement being consummated (December 8, 1877); the Hanwell sale advertisement and news item (July 13, 1878); the firm’s “Wissahickon and Hanwell Mills Papers” advertisements (August 24 and October 12, 1878; April 5, 1879); “Alex. Balfour is moving the machinery from the Wissahickon Mill” (April 28, 1883). The Balfour co-lease (1878) and purchase (1879) sub-claims were not found in the issues searched and remain unverified.
  6. Hexamer General Surveys indexes — the GeoHistory Network full index (plate 128, 1866, for this seat) and the Free Library / Philadelphia Architects and Buildings listings (HGSv2.0128; the Hanwell plate HGSv4.0272, naming Edward Magarge; the Dove Mills and Spring Lawn plates) — read.
  7. Friends of the Wissahickon, “Roadhouses of the Wissahickon” — read in full. The Lotus Inn built from the demolished Megargee Mills, closed 1916.
  8. Affel Canoe Club study notes, citing Contosta & Franklin, Metropolitan Paradise, ch. 4, p. 16 — carried at citation grade, not read at first hand: the “Upper Magargee Mill, built in 1737” drawing caption.
  9. Library Company of Philadelphia, Berry collection note — carried at catalog-note grade: the road’s older name, “Weiss’s (Wise) Mill Road.”
  10. The Megargee/Balfour sequence is the frame the Journal verification was checked against. Macfarlan (1949) was not read — a permanent gap for this seat, as for the valley generally.

Printed gaps and conflicts


A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, it is welcome here — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home