Roxborough · known from the tax lists · 1774–1783

The Roxborough Tax-List MillsThe Roxborough Tax-List Mills

Three of the biggest mills in Roxborough in 1781 stand in the tax lists — and on no map, in no list of seats, and in no later account at all

This page is not about one mill. It is about a small group of grist mills in Roxborough Township that survive in exactly one kind of record: the Pennsylvania tax lists of the 1770s and 1780s. The lists name the miller, tag his trade, and put a value on his property. They do not say where in the township his mill stood, what water turned its wheel, or what became of it.

No seat has been fixed for any of these mills — not one. No drawing, photograph, or survey of any of them exists, and none is expected: a mill whose ground is unknown leaves no picture. The mills on this page are separate mills, and they are not merged into one. What follows is what the lists prove, what they do not prove, and the one attempt to pin a seat down — which failed honestly.

The three millers

Thomas Rees stands first in the lists. In 1781 he is tagged “miller” and valued at £989 — one of the two largest mill valuations in Roxborough that year, behind only the Care and Livezey seats. In 1783 the list tags him with a grist mill. An Evan Rees stands in the 1779 list: probable kin, and not merged with him here.

Henry Pannebecker stands in two lists, seven years apart — a career, not a mention. In 1774 the list prints his name “Pennypacker” and tags him with a grist mill. In 1781 he is “miller,” valued at £723.

Richard Umstad stands in one list only: “miller” in 1781, valued at £964 — among the township’s four largest mill valuations that year, on a single tagged line. A John Umstatt stands in the 1779 list: probable kin, and not merged. The Roxborough Umstads were a landholding family, so a deed trail for Richard is plausible — but the deed books are paper records, and under this project’s online-only rule that trail stands unbuilt.

Two more names stand in the same lists at a lower grade, and they are recorded so the group is complete. Sebastian Fisher was taxed in Roxborough in 1779 and tagged “miller” there in 1781. Adam Prutzman held a grist mill in 1774, and a Conrad Prutsman was taxed in 1779. Both read as likely tenant millers at creek seats; neither has a seat fixed. The group is five names, not three.

Big mills that no map names

The valuations are the scale of these mills, and they are working-mill figures. In the same years, the township’s known creek seats stand in the same band — the Gorgas seat’s grist mill was valued at 800 in 1785. Mills valued from £723 to £989 were mills of the first rank, not stones in a farmyard.

Yet the famous list of the creek’s mills names none of them. In 1779 Horatio Gates Jones set down eleven Roxborough mills in creek order, and every one of the eleven is placed — but there is no Rees, no Pannebecker, and no Umstad among them. Two readings stand open. The men may have ground as tenants at seats Jones listed under the owners’ names. Or their mills stood on water his creek list did not cover.

This project’s own sweep of the lists places all three men on the creek system. That placement is an inference, and it is printed as one: the lists themselves name no water at all, and Roxborough also held mills on its Schuylkill slope and on its small runs.

The one attempt: Rees’ Print Works

Sixty years on, the name Rees turns up on Roxborough industry once more. The Free Library’s index of Charles Ellet Jr.’s 1843 map of the county names “Rees’ Print Works: Eliza’s Lane (Roxborough).” A print works is a calico-printing shop — a shop that prints patterns on cloth. It is one of the few Roxborough textile works the map’s index names, alongside the Gorgas factory and Haley’s dye works.

The lane itself can be partly traced. The Lafayette Hotel stood at Ridge Road and Eliza’s Lane, by the index of Barnes’s 1865 map. By 1862, Crease’s Chemical Works stood on Eliza’s Lane above Ridge Avenue. It was a lane off the Ridge in lower Roxborough, carrying chemical and printing trades in turn.

Detail of Charles Ellet Jr.'s 1843 map showing Eliza's Lane, Roxborough, with the works at the lane labeled Crease's Works
Detail of Charles Ellet Jr.’s 1843 map of Philadelphia County at Eliza’s Lane, Roxborough. The works drawn at the lane is labeled “Crease’s Works” on the map’s face. The Free Library’s index of this map names a “Rees’ Print Works” at Eliza’s Lane, but no “Rees” label is printed at the lane on the map itself. This detail runs as map context for the group’s one namesake lead — it is not a picture of any tax-list mill. Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

But the attempt fails, and it fails on the record. Nothing read puts the print works at the lane’s creek end, proves it ran on water power, or ties its Rees to the miller of 1781. A grandson, a namesake, a tenant’s successor — all are possible, and none can be proved from the online record. Thomas Rees’s seat stays unfixed. The print works stands as this group’s one lead: the only later Rees works in the township in anything read.

Pannebecker and Umstad: no thread to pull

For the other two men, not even an attempt is available. The Pannebecker name belongs famously to Skippack — Hendrick Pannebecker, the surveyor — but nothing read ties the Roxborough Henry to that family, and he is not merged with them. For Umstad, the family’s Roxborough land is the only thread, and it runs through deed books that exist on paper only.

The end

All of these mills are gone. No closing, fire, taking, or demolition record was found for any of them. If any stood inside the ground the Fairmount Park Commission began acquiring in 1868, the general pattern of those years is the context: taken buildings “torn down or became derelict and decayed,” with the WPA finishing the work in the 1930s. That pattern is printed here as context only — not as any one mill’s fate.

The standard accounts of the valley give these men nothing at all: no map, no list of seats, no later history names them. The tax lists alone prove that in 1781 three of Roxborough’s largest mills were turning under names no one can now put on the ground. Whether the list of 1779 hides them under other men’s names, or the creek held more mills than the famous list counts, is a genuine open question — and it stays open here.

Timeline

YearEventSource
1774Henry Pannebecker, printed “Pennypacker,” is taxed with a grist mill; Adam Prutzman is taxed with a grist millPennsylvania tax lists, via the project’s tax-list sweep (SWEEP-26)
1779Jones’s list sets down eleven Roxborough mills in creek order; none of the three is named. Evan Rees and John Umstatt stand in the year’s tax listJones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187; SWEEP-26
1781Thomas Rees, “miller,” £989; Richard Umstad, “miller,” £964; Henry Pannebecker, “miller,” £723; Sebastian Fisher, “miller”SWEEP-26
1783Thomas Rees is taxed with a grist millSWEEP-26
1843Ellet’s map index names “Rees’ Print Works: Eliza’s Lane (Roxborough)”Free Library index, item 11764
1862Crease’s Chemical Works stands on Eliza’s Lane above Ridge AvenueAtlas of the City of Philadelphia, 1862, Section 20 index

The Cellar

The mill dossier behind this story (read)

  1. The project’s dossier for the Roxborough tax-list mills (DOSSIER-roxborough-tax-list-mills.md) — read in full: the three millers and the two floor-grade names, all from the tax-list layer; the valuations weighed against the known creek seats; Jones’s eleven of 1779; the Rees print-works attempt and its verdict — the seat does not fix; the conflicts and permanent gaps printed there and carried here.

The tax lists and the project’s lists (read)

  1. The project’s tax-list sweep (SWEEP-26), from the Pennsylvania tax lists, Pennsylvania Archives, 3rd series — read: Thomas Rees (“miller,” 1781, £989; grist mill, 1783); Henry Pannebecker, printed “Pennypacker” (grist mill, 1774; “miller,” 1781, £723); Richard Umstad (“miller,” 1781, £964); Sebastian Fisher (taxed 1779; “miller,” 1781) and Adam Prutzman (grist mill, 1774; a Conrad Prutsman taxed 1779) at floor grade; Evan Rees and John Umstatt in the 1779 list as probable kin, not merged.
  2. The biography project’s master figure list (MASTER-FIGURE-LIST-v3.0.md), entries 169 (Rees), 170 (Pannebecker), 171 (Umstad), and 174 (Fisher) — read: the entries as the project carries them, flags included.

Maps, indexes, and the Eliza’s Lane trace (read)

  1. Free Library of Philadelphia digital indexes — read: Ellet 1843 (item 11764): “Rees’ Print Works: Eliza’s Lane (Roxborough)”; Barnes 1865 (via DPLA): “Lafayette Hotel: Ridge Road & Eliza’s Lane (lower center-Roxborough)”; Atlas of the City of Philadelphia, 1862, Section 20 (item 12334): “Crease’s Chemical Works: Eliza’s Lane above Ridge Avenue (Roxborough).”
  2. Philadelphia Historical Commission, Ridge Avenue Roxborough Historic District nomination, “Early 19th Century” (via rmwhs.org) — read: Ellet’s three Roxborough textile works (Gorgas, Haley’s, Rees’).
  3. Wikimedia Commons file record — read via the Commons API: the Ellet 1843 detail at Eliza’s Lane (Library of Congress item 2012592211; public domain) — the map detail on this page, captioned at its honest limit: the works drawn there reads “Crease’s Works,” and no “Rees” label is printed at the lane.

The accounts they are weighed against (read)

  1. Horatio Gates Jones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187 — the eleven mills of 1779, none of them these men’s — as quoted in the Holgate genealogy compilation and the Ridge Avenue nomination (both read); carried at that grade.
  2. Jane Mork Gibson, Workshop of the World (1990), Fairmount Park chapter — read: the 1868 acquisition pattern, printed on this page as context only.
  3. The project’s dossier for Benjamin Gorgas (DOSSIER-benjamin-gorgas.md) — read: the Gorgas seat’s 1785 grist-mill valuation of 800, the comparison figure used above.

Project files

  1. The mills index (entry 8, the Roxborough tax-list mills).

A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, the project welcomes it — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home