Jonathan Moore’s sawmill stood on Ridge Avenue in Roxborough, where the avenue crosses Wissahickon Creek at the creek’s mouth — in the creek-mouth mill row, on the Roxborough side. That is where the record puts it, and the record is short: three lines in city directories, printed across four years, are the whole of it. No picture of it survives.
Nothing of the sawmill stands today. The Ridge Avenue crossing is still there, over the creek at its mouth; no source read for this story reports any part of the mill standing.
Three lines in the directories
In 1857, McElroy’s Philadelphia city directory lists Jonathan Moore with a saw mill on Ridge Avenue above the Wissahickon — “saw mill R av ab Wissahickon,” in the directory’s short hand. In 1858 the same directory lists him again: a saw mill on Ridge Avenue below the Wissahickon.
Above the creek one year, below it the next. The flip is in the directories themselves, and no account explains it, because no account mentions the mill at all.
The likely reading is one mill at the crossing, described loosely — written up from one side of the creek in one year and from the other side in the next. That reading is printed here as likely, not as proven. Two sawmill seats, or a move across the creek within the year, cannot be ruled out on anything read. What the flip does not allow is splitting the man in two: the operator of both lines is Jonathan Moore, one man, in both years.
Not John Moore, not Jonathan Robeson
Two other names sit close to his at this creek mouth, and the records keep them apart. John Moore — a different Christian name, and a generation earlier — was the son-in-law who rented the Robeson rolling mill and nail works in 1820. He is not this man. Jonathan Robeson, Peter Robeson’s son, carried the same first name at the same crossing. He is not this man either. Jonathan Moore the saw miller stands in the directories on his own, and this story keeps him there.
The last sawmill at the creek mouth
A sawmill at this crossing was nothing new. Richard Townsend’s sawmill had stood at the mouth of the Wissahickon in the 1680s, on the same ground. Moore’s mill, nearly two centuries later, is the last sawmill the record shows at the creek mouth — standing there in 1857–58, in the very years when the Greenwoods, Lord, and Sutton were working in the mill village just below the crossing.
How the mill was powered, the directories do not say. Water from the creek, steam, or a small circular-saw yard on the road are all possible; none is proven. No census of manufactures return for it was read, and no count of its workers or its output exists in anything read.
Its short life — two years as a sawmill, then a farmer at the same seat — fits a small roadside sawmill cutting for the building trade of a Roxborough that was already turning suburban: the district’s history records house lots and commuter building along Ridge Avenue from 1839 on. That is context, printed as context — not proof of what Moore’s sawmill cut.
A farmer by 1860?
In 1860 the directory prints one more line, and it may be the same man: “Moore Jonathan R., farmer, Ridge av n Wissahickon” — Jonathan R. Moore, a farmer, on Ridge Avenue near the Wissahickon. The seat is the same. The trade has changed, from saw miller to farmer.
The project’s files grade the identification probable: likely him, not proven. If the line is his, the sawmill years were 1857 and 1858, and the seat was a farm again by 1860. If it is not his, Jonathan Moore the saw miller vanishes after 1858, and nothing more is known. Both readings stand. No earlier or later sighting of a Jonathan Moore at the creek was found in the directory rounds the project read, which run from 1857 to 1871.
The end, unrecorded
No closing, sale, fire, or tearing-down of this sawmill is recorded in anything read. It leaves the directories after 1858, and that is all.
The ground it stood on lay in the creek-mouth mill row that the Fairmount Park Commission began buying up after 1868, demolishing mills as it went. That is the row’s documented fate, printed here as the setting. It is not this mill’s proven end.
What could settle the story sits on paper, not online: the census of manufactures schedules for Roxborough, the Park Commission’s briefs of title at the City Archives, and Macfarlan’s 1949 typescript on the Wissahickon mills, kept in the Free Library’s Map Room. This project works from the online record alone, so those stay unread, and the gaps stay printed.
No picture to show
This page carries no picture of the sawmill, because none exists to show. No drawing, photograph, or survey of Moore’s mill was found in any source read. The Hexamer insurance surveys, whose drawings picture so many of the creek’s mills, covered only the mill village’s one large insured plant — not a two-year roadside sawmill. So the page stands without a picture, rather than with one borrowed from another mill.
Timeline
| Year | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1857 | Jonathan Moore, saw mill, Ridge Avenue above the Wissahickon | McElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1857 |
| 1858 | Jonathan Moore, saw mill, Ridge Avenue below the Wissahickon | McElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1858 |
| 1860 | “Moore Jonathan R., farmer, Ridge av n Wissahickon” — probably the same man; the identification is graded probable, not proven | McElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1860, p. 752 |

