The Monastery Seat · on Wissahickon Creek · 1746–1781

John GorgasJohn Gorgas

Two creek seats, three wives, and a mill that took his name

The opening of the deed of March 2, 1746/47 (Philadelphia Deed Book H12, p. 306): the margin reads “Benj.n Shoemaker & Wife to John Gorgas,” and the text styles the buyer “John Gorgas of Germantown… Skin Dresser”
The opening of his purchase — the deed of March 2, 1746/47 (Philadelphia Deed Book H12, p. 306), by which Benjamin Shoemaker and his wife Elizabeth sold John Gorgas, “of Germantown… Skin Dresser,” the mill seat on Wissahickon Creek at Kitchen’s Lane, the ground of the Monastery house. The deed was recorded September 22, 1761, fourteen years after it was made. Public record.

John Gorgas's tie to the Wissahickon comes first, because it is the whole story. In March 1747, John Gorgas (c. 1710–1781), a skin dresser of Germantown, bought about 129 acres on Wissahickon Creek at what is now Kitchen's Lane, inside today's Wissahickon Valley Park — the seat the valley knows for the Monastery, the great stone house his brother Joseph built on the ground that same year. John held the seat in shares for thirteen years; its mill was called "Gorgas's Mill" by 1752. Six months before that purchase he had bought a second seat, about 85 acres below Glen Fern, and that one stayed in his hands until his death: a 1777 deed calls its mill "John Gorgas Senr's Mill," and his estate's partition of 1782 divided its grist mill and oil mill among his sons. He is the man who brought the Gorgas family onto the creek. He is not his father, the John Gorgas who bought into the Crefeld paper mill in 1713, and he is not his son, the John Gorgas who worked the Roxborough mills after him — the records separate all three, and so does this account.

A tradesman's inheritance

He enters the record as an heir. His father's will (June 1, 1741) names him eldest son, gives him the first half of the family fulling mill in Germantown and half the small piece of ground it stood on, makes him an executor beside his mother Sophia, and leaves £5 to his own son John — so he was a father by 1741. No record read names the stream the fulling mill stood on, and this account does not place it on the Wissahickon; Germantown had the Wingohocking too. His birth year is a compiled estimate, about 1710, printed as compiled. What the records do prove is his trade and his timing: by 1746 he had money of his own, and he spent it on the creek.

Two purchases in six months

On August 22, 1746, John Ballay and his wife Mary Sophia sold him two Roxborough tracts — 43¼ acres and 42 acres 70 perches, about 85 acres below Glen Fern. That deed survives through its recital in a deed of 1777, read in full; the original's index citation does not resolve, and its price and bounds are a printed gap.

On March 2, 1746/47, Benjamin Shoemaker and his wife Elizabeth sold him the Kitchen's Lane seat: about 129 acres on the creek in four pieces, one of them with a dwelling already on it, for £354. The deed — read in the original for this biography — styles him "John Gorges of Germantown, skin dresser," a dresser of hides; the Germantown historian Hotchkin, who called him a tanner, had the trade right. The deed then hid in plain sight: it was not recorded until September 1761, fourteen years late, in a book far from its date, and print accounts carried the seat's story for generations without it. It surfaced through the deed grantor index.

A seat held in shares

He never held the Monastery seat whole. In November 1747 he and his wife Mary conveyed an undivided half of the smaller pieces and 27 acres to Michael Pelsner and Jacob Simon. In 1747 his brother Joseph built the Monastery house on the two-acre house lot. In April 1752 an Adam Gorgas — unidentified, not among the children of the 1741 will, and left unidentified here — conveyed a fourth part of that lot to Joseph. And on July 6, 1752, John and Mary conveyed Joseph a half of the house lot for £8, in the deed that names the seat's mill: "Gorgas's Mill," on Wissahickon Creek, its lot bounded from the north corner of the grist mill. A grist mill stood there by 1752 and bore the family name. Who built it, no record read says — John owned the seat, Joseph lived on it as miller — and this account prints the fact and the dates, not a builder.

In December 1760, with a second wife, Regina, signing beside him, John sold Joseph his remaining share of the seat's "Mill Lands" for a full £600. In April 1761, styled in the deed "miller" and "eldest son of John Gorgas," he settled the last of the brothers' mill shares with Joseph, adding a right of road over his own Germantown land and the right to dam the creek to the mill's height. Joseph sold the house lot out of the family that year. The seat passed to Milner, then to Peter Care in 1775, and in time to the Fairmount Park Commission.

The seat below Glen Fern

The Ballay land was his for life. In July 1770 he and his third wife, Rachel, conveyed part of it to his eldest son John. In May 1777 that son, "John Gorgas Junior, miller of Roxborough," sold a lot on the great road to Reading, and the deed locates it "by the road to John Gorgas Senr's Mill" — the father's name still on the mill in the neighbourhood's speech.

The Roxborough tax lists tell father and son apart. In 1779 the list rates a "John Gorgas Junr" — for himself, and again "for Jn.o Gorgas &c." In 1780 three lines stand together: "John Gorgas, Miller" at 20,100; "Benjn Gorgas, Oylmiller" at 22,100; and "John Gorgas Senr" at 33,000, the family's largest valuation, no trade styled. In 1781 the senior line is gone, in the year his will was proved. The senior is the father, rated on the seat he bought in 1746; the junior — the "Miller" of 1780–81, the "Oylmiller" of the years after — is the son who worked it. Compiled accounts had given the 1779 miller to the father; the list names a junior, and the correction is printed here. His home township's lists add his Germantown footing: 17 acres and a dwelling in 1774, rated again in 1779 and in 1780, the last year on "Cash £500." Hotchkin's "tanner who ran the old mill" is the same two men in one sentence: the tanner is the father, the mill-running of those years the son's.

His will, and the great partition

His will (May 28, 1780) leaves "all my Lands, Mills, Tenements & Hereditaments whatsoever or wheresoever" in equal shares to his five sons and four youngest daughters — ten children in all, the eldest daughter not among the devisees, for reasons no record gives — with his widow Rachel to take a third of the annual rents for life, and his sons John and Benjamin as executors. It was proved December 12, 1781. His estate inventory, due the following January, does not survive in the online files; the search was made jacket by jacket and is printed in the sources.

On September 1, 1782, five referees partitioned the estate into nine equal shares, Rachel to take £5 a year from each in place of dower. The eldest son John took the stone messuage and the oil mill on Oyst Mill Run — Oil Mill Run, at Glen Fern — 14 acres 120 perches: the oil mill the tax lists style him by from 1785. Benjamin took the messuage and grist mill, its lot running from the run by the mill road down to Wissahickon Creek — 25 acres 60 perches by the partition, 24 acres 60 perches by the deed that followed. For Jacob had conveyed his ninth to Benjamin the day before the partition, and the day after it Benjamin sold Jacob back an undivided half of the grist mill for £380 11s 1d — which is why, in 1786, the tax list rates Benjamin and Jacob at half the grist mill each, and John at the oil mill whole. The grist mill Benjamin held is the mill of the later dam dispute with the Livezeys of Glen Fern, told in Benjamin's own entry in this collection. Its first name, though, was its founder's: John Gorgas Senr's mill.

What the record does not say

His birth year is compiled. His inventory is lost. The Ballay deed's price is unread. The Monastery seat's grist mill has no named builder. Adam Gorgas, who held a fourth of the house lot in 1752, is nobody the records explain. In 1767 a John Gorgas acted as his brother Joseph's executor beside the widow Juliana — Joseph's will calls that executor "Junr," which points to the nephew; the newspaper notices pair a plain John with the widow, which reads as the brother; the question stands open. His Germantown tax lines are read for 1774, 1779, and 1780; the years between are bounded negatives. Rachel is found once more in 1820, heading her own Germantown household of two women, both past forty-five by the census index. What stands is the spine: a Germantown skin dresser who bought two seats on Wissahickon Creek in six months, put his family's name on a mill, and left the second seat to nine children.

Timeline

DateEvent
c. 1710Born, eldest son of John Gorgas of Germantown (compiled date)
June 1, 1741Father's will: half the family fulling mill, co-executor; already a father himself
August 22, 1746Buys the Roxborough seat below Glen Fern from John Ballay — two tracts, about 85 acres
March 2, 1746/47Buys the Monastery mill seat at Kitchen's Lane from Benjamin Shoemaker — about 129 acres, £354; styled "skin dresser"
November 25, 1747With wife Mary, conveys a moiety of parts of the seat to Michael Pelsner and Jacob Simon
April 10, 1752Adam Gorgas (unidentified) conveys a fourth part of the house lot to Joseph Gorgas
July 6, 1752With Mary, conveys a moiety of the house lot to Joseph; the deed names "Gorgas's Mill" on the creek
December 21, 1760With wife Regina, sells Joseph his moiety of the "Mill Lands" for £600
April 28, 1761Settles the seat's grist and saw mill shares with Joseph; dam right and mill road granted
July 9, 1770With wife Rachel, conveys Roxborough-seat land to his eldest son John
1774Rated in his home township, Germantown: 17 acres, a dwelling, 2 cows — with £70 of his son John junior's money rated under his name
May 2, 1777His son's deed names the seat's mill "John Gorgas Senr's Mill"
1779–1780Rated in Roxborough beside his sons; in 1780 as "John Gorgas Senr," 33,000
May 28, 1780His will: nine equal shares to five sons and four youngest daughters; Rachel to take a third of the rents for life
December 12, 1781Will proved — he died in 1781, the day unrecorded
September 1, 1782Partition of his estate: the oil mill to his eldest son John, the grist mill to Benjamin
September 2, 1782Benjamin sells Jacob an undivided half of the grist mill for £380 11s 1d
1786Tax list: Benjamin and Jacob at half the grist mill each; John at the oil mill

The Cellar

Primary (read)

  1. Deed, Benjamin Shoemaker & Elizabeth to John Gorgas, March 2, 1746/47, Philadelphia Deed Book H12, pp. 306–308 (FamilySearch DGS 008067341, images 158–159) — read in the original, November 16, 2026; located via the Grantor Index M–S (DGS 8067249, image 685).
  2. Deed, John Gorgas & Mary to Joseph Gorgas, July 6, 1752, Deed Book H2, pp. 356–359 (DGS 008067336, images 185–186) — read in the original, November 16, 2026.
  3. Deed, Adam Gorgas & Susannah to Joseph Gorgas, April 10, 1752, Deed Book H2, pp. 359–361 (images 186–187).
  4. Deed, John Gorgas & Regina to Joseph Gorgas, December 21, 1760, Deed Book H12, pp. 302–305.
  5. Will of John Gorgas (the father), Will Book F, p. 221, dated June 1, 1741, proved June 22, 1741 (DGS 7726373, images 123–124) — read for the father's entry.
  6. Will of John Gorgas (this man), Will Book S, pp. 44–45 (DGS 7726378, image 324), dated May 28, 1780, proved December 12, 1781 — read for the father's entry.
  7. Will of Rachel Gorgas, Will Book 8, p. 462, dated April 29, 1818, proved August 13, 1825 (DGS 7726384, image 567) — read for Benjamin Gorgas's entry.
  8. Pennsylvania Gazette, March 5, 1767 (and April 2, April 23, May 14, 1767) — the executors' vendue of Joseph Gorgas's Germantown and Cresheim lots (Readex, read November 16, 2026).
  9. Philadelphia administration files, 1781–1782 (FamilySearch catalog olib:1876726; DGS 5872189, 5872190) — searched jacket by jacket, November 16, 2026; no Gorgas file.
  10. Roxborough Township tax lists, 1779 (pp. 238–239), 1780 (pp. 60–61), 1781 (p. 54), 1782 (pp. 408–409), 1786 (p. 311) — the project's Ancestry harvest, Item 53 images, read from the images November 16, 2026.
  11. Deed, John Gorgas to Joseph Gorgas, April 28, 1761, Deed Book I14, pp. 303–304 — the Monastery seat's grist and saw mill share, the mill road, and the dam right (read November 16, 2026).
  12. Deed, John Gorgas Junior & Margaret to Michael Bargendollar, May 2, 1777, Deed Book D46, pp. 132–135 — reciting the Ballay purchase of August 22, 1746 and the conveyance of July 9, 1770 from John Gorgas Sr. and Rachel (read November 16, 2026).
  13. Deed, Christian Dorst, John Gorgas & Margaret his wife, and others to Benjamin Gorgas, September 20, 1781, Deed Book D4, p. 153 (DGS 008067354, images 80–81) — Rittenhouse-inheritance shares in two Cresheim lots; the grantor John's identification is open — read, not folded into the timeline.
  14. Deed Book D11, p. 222 — checked November 16, 2026 (DGS 008067357, image 114): no John Gorgas to Benjamin Gorgas deed stands there; the index line behind the citation resolves in the Grantor Index G to "Jacob Gorgas, et al., to Benjamin Gorgas" — an index error, closed.
  15. "Deed Book I41, p. 206" — citation unresolvable, checked November 16, 2026: no volume I41 exists in the Philadelphia deed catalog (the I series runs 1–17), and Deed Book D41, p. 206 (DGS 008067371, image 107), holds unrelated deeds of 1796. Closed as an index error, with item 14.
  16. Partition of the estate of John Gorgas, signed September 1, 1782 — read in full November 16, 2026 in Deed Book D45, pp. 449–455 (DGS 008067373, images 216–219), recorded February 11, 1783 (the deed index gives February 11, 1785 — printed as a conflict). The instrument's original recording was in "Book No. 45," p. 429 ff.; a Jacob Gorgas deed of 1796 (EF 9) cites the deed poll at that page.
  17. Deed, Benjamin Gorgas and Juliana his wife to Jacob Gorgas, September 2, 1782, Deed Book D13 (DGS 008067358, image 186) — read November 16, 2026.
  18. Germantown Township tax lines for John Gorgas — 1774 (Archive Roll 332), 1779 (Roll 333, three records), 1780 (Roll 334, p. 67) — Pennsylvania, U.S., Tax and Exoneration, 1768–1801 (Ancestry collection 2497), the project's Ancestry harvest, Item 63; full-resolution receipts filed and read from the images, November 16, 2026. Bounded negatives for 1769–1773, 1775–1778, and 1781 under the searches recorded in the dossier.
  19. 1820 U.S. census, Germantown, Philadelphia County — "Rachel Gorges," roll M33_109, p. 107-B: a household of 2, both free white females 45 and over per the index (the project's Ancestry harvest, Item 63; viewer-screenshot receipt).
  20. Bounded searches, the project's Ancestry harvest, Item 63: Adam Gorgas in the Philadelphia will index (collection 4695), church and town records (2451), tax and exoneration (2497), and the 1790/1800 censuses (5058, 7590) — no record tying him to the family; Rachel Gorgas in the 1790–1810 censuses (5058, 7590, 7613) — not identified; a John Gorgas burial, 1780–1782, Germantown, in collection 2451 — none found.

Secondary (read)

  1. Scharf & Westcott, History of Philadelphia (1884), vol. 2, p. 1315 (after Horatio Gates Jones, 1859) — the print account of the 1747/1752/1761 conveyances; superseded in detail by primary items 1–4, which it matches in sequence.
  2. Hotchkin, Germantown, Crefeld and vicinity (1889), as harvested in the project's Sweep 22 — this John "a tanner who ran the old mill" in Roxborough; the trade corroborated by primary items 1–2 ("skin dresser"), the mill-running graded in the text.
  3. The project's Sweep 11 — the compiled identification giving a birth about 1710 and assigning the 1779 tax list's John to this man; the birth year is printed as compiled, and the tax assignment is not sustained.

Version B of the John Gorgas (c. 1710–1781) biography, Wissahickon Historical Biographies. Written from DOSSIER-john-gorgas-son.md, graded COMPLETE under the completion test as amended November 11, 2026. The gaps and conflicts in the dossier are carried here as printed gaps and conflicts.

---


A note on sources. This biography was researched online from the public record — deeds, censuses, tax lists, newspapers, court reports, and probate files — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, the project welcomes it — corrections make the record better.

Back to Historical Figures

Back Home