Roxborough · on Wissahickon Creek · 1779–1927

Gorgas MillGorgas Mill

Two brothers, two mills, and a dam whose lawful height was set by a hole bored in a rock — the grist mill and oil mill at the foot of Gorgas Lane

The Gorgas mill seat stood on Wissahickon Creek in Roxborough, at the foot of Gorgas Lane, just below Livezey’s mill at Glen Fern. Two mills worked on the seat: a water grist mill, which grinds grain into meal and flour, and an oil mill, which pressed oil from seed.

The Gorgas name needs care on this creek, because it sits on three different grounds. This seat is not the Monastery mill seat on Kitchen’s Lane, two miles up the creek, though the same family opens both stories. And it is not Gorgas Park, on Ridge Avenue at Hermitage Street — the Joseph Gorgas homestead tract, no mill of this seat’s kind on it; the park is not this mill’s ground, and no evidence for it. The surname alone fixes nothing here. The records fix this seat.

No picture of the buildings survives: no photograph or survey drawing of the works was found in anything read. The old maps name the seat but do not draw it; the one image on this page is a map detail, printed as a map, not a portrait of the mill.

Fixed by the records

Four witnesses fix the seat. The lawsuit over the dam — Levezey v. Gorgas, reported at 4 Dallas 61 — puts the Gorgas grist mill on the creek below the Livezeys’ mill, and the Gorgas dam is the suit’s subject. A situated list of 1779 puts John Gorgas’s grist mill and Benjamin Gorgas’s oil mill ninth and tenth, immediately below Thomas Livezey’s grist mill, eleventh. The maps agree: Ellet’s map of 1843 names a “Gorgas Cotton Factory” where Gorgas Lane meets the creek, and Barnes’s of 1855 still names “Gorgas’ Factory” above Levering’s Lane — today’s Leverington Avenue. And the lane keeps a witness: its little stream was still called “Oil Mill Run” when Brandt walked it in 1927.

Two brothers, two mills

The Roxborough tax lists show how the seat was divided between the two brothers who held it. In 1780 Benjamin Gorgas is entered as “Oylmiller,” in 1781 as “Oil Miller,” while his brother John is the plain “Miller”: John ran the grist mill, Benjamin the oil mill.

Then the brothers changed places — or divided the seat again. By 1785 Benjamin holds “1 Grist Mill” and John the “Oyl Mill”; John still holds the oil mill in 1786, when Benjamin holds half the grist mill and Jacob Gorgas the other half. In 1789 Benjamin holds the whole grist mill again, on 72 acres. The exchange is written nowhere but in these tax lines.

Which Benjamin the miller was, the record leaves open: the family held more than one — an uncle’s generation and a nephew’s — and the evidence runs toward the nephew without settling it. It is carried here as open, as the project’s Benjamin Gorgas biography carries it.

The work of the seat

The grist mill did merchant and country work both — the words are the seat’s own, from its 1798 sale advertisement: grinding grain for the market, and the neighbours’ grain for the neighbours. The oil mill pressed oil from seed; which seed, no record read names. Benjamin Gorgas is the only oil miller the valley’s records name, and the trade stands on this seat alone.

The tax lines price the seat: the grist mill at 800 in 1785, on a line with 60 acres and two dwellings totalling £1,310; the oil mill’s line at 575 in 1781; the grist mill at 450 by 1789.

The dam war

The seat’s water was fought over in the 1790s. The Livezeys, who had held their mill at Glen Fern since 1790, charged that the Gorgases had raised their dam, penned the water back, and broke the Livezey works. The case went to four referees — men appointed to settle it outside a courtroom — and their award was exact. It fixed the lawful height of the Gorgas dam by “the bottom of the hole bored in a certain rock” on the creek’s north-east side. It allowed the Livezeys, after notice and a freeholders’ view, to enter and pull the dam down themselves if it were raised higher. And it charged the mill’s holders £50, and £10 yearly, for the privilege of the dam.

The Supreme Court confirmed the award in 1796. On January 17, 1800, the High Court of Errors and Appeals reversed it, holding the referees had gone beyond the question put to them. The report names the losing side only as “Gorgas et al.” — Benjamin’s own place among the defendants is probable, not proven. How the two seats shared the water after 1800, no record read says.

Sold out of the name

On October 10, 1798, Claypoole’s American Daily Advertiser offered “a valuable Merchant, Country and Oil Mill, known by the name of Gorgas’s Mill; situate in Roxborough township… on Wissahickon creek,” with 25 acres — the combined plant, advertised whole. By January 1800 the name was already past tense: advertisements for the Rever plantation bounded their land by “Wisse’s or late Gorgas’s mill.” Who Wisse was, nothing else read says; he is printed as the advertisement gives him, and not merged with the Wise family of the paper mills up the creek at Wise’s Mill Road — a like name is not the same man.

The name did not leave the ground at once: Hotchkin’s history of the county (1889), as carried in the project files, says a John Gorgas of the next generation “ran the old mill” in Roxborough, and no dates or figures go with the line in anything read.

The cotton factory

By 1843 the seat had changed trades. Ellet’s map names it the Gorgas Cotton Factory, and Barnes’s map still names it Gorgas’ Factory in 1855. The name on the maps is the place’s, not a proprietor’s: who ran the cotton years, nothing read says.

Detail of Charles Ellet Jr.'s 1843 map showing Gorgas' Cotton F. at Gorgas Lane on Wissahickon Creek
Detail of Charles Ellet Jr.’s 1843 map of Philadelphia County: “Gorgas’ Cotton F.” where Gorgas Lane meets Wissahickon Creek — the map’s own printed name for this seat. A map detail shows the seat and its printed name, not the buildings. Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

The dyers

The seat’s last working chapter belongs to dyers. Cyrus Carmany found work in a Roxborough dye works by 1868. The census of 1880 shows Cyrus, and his sons John and Edmund, employed at the dye works, the family at 366 Green Lane. The Philadelphia directory of 1886 puts John H. Carmany on Gorgas Lane near the Wissahickon, where Cyrus and James Boone were partners — the firm of Carmany & Boone.

One caution belongs here. The Camden history behind the dyers’ story fixes them to Gorgas Lane, not to this building. Haley’s Dye Works stood on the same lane. Their placement on this seat is the one the project files carry; the other possibility stands beside it, not hidden.

In 1887 Cyrus Carmany bought a site in Camden and took the business across the river, trading there as the Wissahickon Dye Works. That December the Camden plant burned, and the Trenton Evening Times reported that “Mr. Carmany had but recently removed his business from a mill on the Wissahickon creek, and employed sixteen hands.” The sixteen hands are the business’s as it left the creek, printed at that grade.

The end

No taking, sale, fire, or demolition record naming this seat was found in anything read. When the Fairmount Park Commission began acquiring the valley’s mill sites in 1868, the list Gibson’s Workshop of the World gives does not name a Gorgas mill. The ground lay at the park’s edge, and its end was later and quieter than the taken mills’.

About 1872 the city still mapped the seat: the Streets Department plan of the Sixteenth Section, bounded by Gorgas Lane and Leverington Avenue, shows “ponds, factory and mill race” — the works still standing to be surveyed in the park’s first years. The 1917 revision lists building footprints only — no factory, no race. Between the surveys, the works leave the mapped record.

The last sighting is Brandt’s, in 1927: on Gorgas Lane “one soon sees on the left the remains of the ‘Haunted Mill,’ burned down, it is said, seventeen times.” The seventeen burnings are the lane’s legend, printed here as legend — not as this mill’s fire history, for which no record was read.

Three records that might say more stand as permanent gaps, outside this project’s online reach: the 1850 and 1860 manufactures schedules for the 21st Ward — the cotton factory’s figures, if any were returned; the deed books behind the sale of 1798–1800; and a 1949 typescript on the valley’s mills, kept on paper at the Free Library. What remains is the lane itself, and the little run beside it, still keeping the oil mill’s name.

Timeline

YearEventSource
1779Jones’s list: John Gorgas’s grist mill (9) and Benjamin Gorgas’s oil mill (10), just below Thomas Livezey’s grist mill (11)Jones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187, as quoted
1780Benjamin taxed as “Oylmiller”; John as the plain “Miller”Roxborough tax lines, via the Benjamin Gorgas dossier
1781Benjamin “Oil Miller”; the oil mill’s line valued 575Roxborough tax lines
1785The brothers have swapped: Benjamin holds 1 Grist Mill (800); John holds the Oyl MillRoxborough tax lines
1786Benjamin holds ½ Grist Mill (400) and Jacob Gorgas the other half; John still holds the Oyl MillRoxborough tax lines
1789Benjamin holds 1 Grist Mill (450) on 72 acresRoxborough tax lines
1796The dam award confirmed in the Supreme CourtLevezey v. Gorgas, 4 Dall. 61
1798“Gorgas’s Mill” — merchant, country, and oil mill on 25 acres — advertised whole, October 10Claypoole’s American Daily Advertiser
1800The dam award reversed, January 17; land bounded by “Wisse’s or late Gorgas’s mill”4 Dall. 61; Claypoole’s
1843Ellet’s map names the seat the Gorgas Cotton FactoryEllet, Map of the County of Philadelphia, 1843
1855Barnes’s map still names it “Gorgas’ Factory”Barnes, New Map of the Consolidated City, 1855
1868Cyrus Carmany at work in a Roxborough dye worksCamden history of John H. Carmany
c. 1872The city survey still maps “ponds, factory and mill race” on the seatStreets Department plan 261-03, via GeoHistory
1880Census: Cyrus Carmany and his sons John and Edmund at the dye works; the family at 366 Green Lane1880 census, via the Camden history
1886Directory: John H. Carmany on Gorgas Lane; Carmany & Boone partners in the dye worksPhiladelphia directory, via the Camden history
1887The dyers remove to Camden as the Wissahickon Dye Works, sixteen handsTrenton Evening Times, December 8, 1887
1917The revised city survey lists building footprints only — no factory, no raceStreets Department plan 261-07, via GeoHistory
1927Brandt sees the remains of the “Haunted Mill” on Gorgas LaneBrandt, The Wissahickon Valley (1927)

The Cellar

The dossiers behind this story (read)

  1. The project’s mill dossier for this seat (DOSSIER-gorgas-mill.md) — read in full: the seat fixed by the lawsuit, the situated list, the maps, and the lane; the owners and operators, 1779–1887; the working mill and its tax-line scale; the end in the city surveys and Brandt’s 1927 sighting; the conflicts and permanent gaps, printed as found.
  2. The project’s biography dossier for Benjamin Gorgas (DOSSIER-benjamin-gorgas.md, entry 20) — read in full for the mill dossier: the Roxborough tax lines 1769–1789 in full transcription (the 1780 “Oylmiller” and 1781 “Oil Miller” lines; the 1785 exchange; the 1786 half-mill; the valuations); Levezey v. Gorgas, 4 Dall. 61, read in Dallas’s reports (the award, the hole bored in the rock, the 1796 confirmation, the January 17, 1800 reversal); the October 10, 1798 “Gorgas’s Mill” advertisement and the January 1800 “Wisse’s or late Gorgas’s mill” bounds, both from Claypoole’s American Daily Advertiser; the generation question, carried open under the project’s reframe (“Benjamin Gorgas of Roxborough, generation left open”); Hotchkin’s “ran the old mill” line as carried in the project files. The £50 of the dam award rests on a damaged passage in the report’s scan; the £10 yearly is legible — graded here as the biography dossier grades it.

Maps, surveys, and the image record (read)

  1. Free Library of Philadelphia digital indexes — Ellet, Map of the County of Philadelphia, 1843 (item 11764): “Gorgas Cotton Factory: Gorgas Lane and Wissahickon Creek (Roxborough)”; Barnes, New Map of the Consolidated City of Philadelphia, 1855 (item MBARAA00001, via DPLA): “Gorgas’ Factory: Wissahickon Creek above Levering’s Lane (Philadelphia: 21st Ward).” The Barnes map is public domain by date, but the Free Library’s copy is served on terms that require permission and no open copy was found; it is cited here, not shown.
  2. Wikimedia Commons file record — read via the Commons API: Charles Ellet Jr.’s Map of the County of Philadelphia, 1843 (Library of Congress item 2012592211; public domain) — the detail shown on this page, its printed label “Gorgas’ Cotton F.” at the lane-and-creek crossing. No photograph or survey of the mill buildings was located in anything read; a search of the Hexamer index in this pass found no survey of the Gorgas Lane works — a bounded negative, not proof none exists.
  3. Greater Philadelphia GeoHistory Network, Philadelphia Streets Department index (philageohistory.org, read) — Plan 261-03 (c. 1872), Sixteenth Section, 21st Ward: “ponds, factory and mill race” between Gorgas Lane and Leverington Avenue; Plan 261-07 (1917 revision): building footprints, no factory or race.

Accounts of the lane, the dyers, and the district (read)

  1. Francis Burke Brandt, The Wissahickon Valley within the City of Philadelphia (1927), “Gorgas Lane and its Caves” — Oil Mill Run beside the lane; “the remains of the ‘Haunted Mill,’ burned down, it is said, seventeen times” — the saying printed as the lane’s legend. archive.org full text, read.
  2. “John H. Carmany” (Camden County Historical Society / DVRBS Camden history, dvrbs.camdenhistory.com, read) — Cyrus Carmany’s Roxborough dye works from 1868; the 1880 census (366 Green Lane); the 1886 directory (Gorgas Lane near the Wissahickon; Carmany & Boone); the 1887 removal to Camden; the Philadelphia Inquirer and Trenton Evening Times of December 8, 1887 (“removed his business from a mill on the Wissahickon creek, and employed sixteen hands”), both as reproduced there. The Camden source fixes the firm to Gorgas Lane, not to this building over Haley’s Dye Works on the same lane; the story prints both placements.
  3. Philadelphia Historical Commission, Ridge Avenue Roxborough Historic District nomination, “Early 19th Century” (via the Roxborough-Manayunk-Wissahickon Historical Society, rmwhs.org, read) — the Ellet map’s three Roxborough textile works: the Gorgas Cotton Factory on Gorgas Lane at the creek, Haley’s Dye Works on Gorgas Lane, Rees’ Print Works on Eliza’s Lane.
  4. Jane Mork Gibson, Workshop of the World (1990), Fairmount Park chapter (workshopoftheworld.com, read) — the 1868 acquisition list: no Gorgas mill named; the general torn-down-or-derelict pattern, context only.
  5. Horatio Gates Jones, The Levering Family (1858), p. 187 — entries 9, 10, and 11 of the situated list of 1779 — as quoted in the Holgate genealogy compilation and the Ridge Avenue nomination (both read); carried at that grade.

Project files

  1. The mills index (entry 6, Gorgas Mill); the biography project’s master figure list (entries 20 and 29); SWEEP-22 and SWEEP-30, as cited in the index.

A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, the project welcomes it — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home