Chestnut Hill · on Wissahickon Creek · 1858–1859

Dixon & Kauffman Paper MillDixon & Kauffman Paper Mill

A paper mill that lives in two lines of a directory

A mill that lives in two lines of a directory

Some mills in this collection left buildings, insurance surveys, court fights, and photographs. This one left two lines in a city directory. In McElroy’s Philadelphia directory for 1858, Thomas Dixon is listed as a paper manufacturer at “Wissahickon (C Hill)” — the Wissahickon Creek, at Chestnut Hill, in the city of Philadelphia. In the same year’s directory, Frederick Kauffman is listed as a paper manufacturer at the same address. That is nearly the whole record of this mill: two directory years, 1858 and 1859, and then nothing. No map read for this account names it. No insurance survey drew it. No newspaper notice of it was found. If it had a name of its own, the record does not give it.

The two names are paired in this account’s title for one reason only: the two men share an address, a trade, and a year. No partnership record between Dixon and Kauffman was read, and none is claimed here.

The crew of 1858

A single directory line can be a paper address — a man taking orders for a mill somewhere else. This mill was more than that, and the same directory proves it. Read one line deeper, past the proprietors, and the 1858 directory names the mill’s crew: four working papermakers at the same “Wissahickon (C Hill)” address — Thomas Ayres, E. M’Bride, Charles Teal, and Jacob Zeigler, each listed as a papermaker there. A mill too small or too short-lived for the maps and the newspapers still employed at least five men, and the directory preserved all five names. Ayres, M’Bride, Teal, and Zeigler appear in no other record read for this account. Their names, and the two years of listings, are the whole of what this seat adds to the valley’s record — and it is not nothing.

Two names, one address

What Frederick Kauffman was to this mill, the directories do not say. He may have been Dixon’s partner. He may have been a rival working the same ground, or Dixon’s successor within the same year. The record gives the two men side by side in 1858 and gives no answer, and this account does not guess. In 1859 Dixon is listed at the address again. A second listing for Kauffman at the address was not found. Whether Kauffman left, died, moved to another mill, or simply fell out of the directory’s net is unknown.

Even Dixon himself is held at arm’s length. The federal census of 1860 shows a “Thos Dickenson” at a paper mill in the Chestnut Hill area — a plausible match for Thomas Dixon in a mangled spelling. It is printed here as a candidate, not an identification. And this Thomas Dixon is not the later Roxborough councilman Dixon of the 1891 railroad charter, and not John W. Dixon of Norristown and Stony Creek. The names are common; the records are separate; nothing merges them.

Where was it?

No record read fixes this mill to a parcel, a road, or a bank of the creek. The whole geography the sources give is the directory’s address: the Wissahickon, at Chestnut Hill. It may have been a short tenancy at one of the known Chestnut Hill seats — the Bell’s Mill seat downstream is the nearest documented paper-capable ground, and the Koch seat upstream had been a paper mill a century earlier. Or it may have been a small works on a side run that no map read labels. Which of those it was is an open question, and it is printed here as a question. This account does not place the mill.

Of the working mill itself, almost nothing can be said. It made paper, with at least five men at the work in 1858. No record read gives its vats, its power, its output, or any name its paper sold under. Its working life in the records is two directory years.

The silence after 1859

After 1859, the record stops. One possible successor stands as a question only: John M. Kelly, listed in McElroy’s directory for 1863 as a manufacturer on Wissahickon Creek. Successor to Dixon, or another seat’s man — unproven either way. No fire, flood, sale, taking for the park, or closure record for this mill was read, and a search beyond the directories, made, found no mill name, no fire notice, and no taking notice for a Dixon or Kauffman paper mill on this creek. The directories remain the whole file.

The file is thin, but it is not closed by its thinness. A Hexamer insurance plate, an entry in the Census of Manufactures, or a newspaper notice naming a Dixon or Kauffman mill on this creek would reopen it at once. The 1860 Census of Manufactures for the Chestnut Hill wards is the obvious next record to look for; that record stands as a permanent gap. Until such a record surfaces, this mill stands as the directories left it: five named men, two years, one creek — and a seat nobody can point to.

Timeline

1858Thomas Dixon is listed in McElroy’s Philadelphia directory as a paper manufacturer at “Wissahickon (C Hill)”; four papermakers — Thomas Ayres, E. M’Bride, Charles Teal, and Jacob Zeigler — are listed at the same address.
1858Frederick Kauffman is listed in the same directory as a paper manufacturer at the same address; his relation to Dixon — partner, rival, or successor — is not stated.
1859Dixon is listed at the address again; no second listing for Kauffman at the address was found.
1860The federal census shows a “Thos Dickenson” at a paper mill in the Chestnut Hill area — a possible match for Dixon in a mangled spelling, printed as a candidate, not an identification.
1863John M. Kelly, a manufacturer on Wissahickon Creek, appears in McElroy’s directory — a possible successor, unproven either way.

The Cellar

Sources

  1. McElroy’s Philadelphia city directories: 1858 (Thomas Dixon, paper manufacturer, “Wissahickon (C Hill),” p. 186; Frederick Kauffman, paper manufacturer, same address, p. 299; the papermaker entries for Thomas Ayres, E. M’Bride, Charles Teal, and Jacob Zeigler, p. 407 and the name entries), 1859 (Dixon, pp. 191, 286, 386), and 1863 (John M. Kelly, manufacturer, Wissahickon Creek) — read.
  2. U.S. federal census, 1860 — the “Thos Dickenson… Paper Mill” entry in the Chestnut Hill area, carried at candidate grade only.
  3. Searches made for a Dixon or Kauffman paper mill on the Wissahickon beyond the directories — negative; the directory transcriptions on genealogy websites are the same McElroy text, not a second source.

Printed gaps and conflicts


A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, it is welcome here — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home