Roxborough · on Ridge Avenue below Wissahickon Lane · 1857–58

Charles Sutton’s ManufactoryCharles Sutton's Manufactory

Two lines in the city directories are the whole of it — a manufacturer on Ridge Avenue in 1857 and 1858, and no record anywhere of what he made

Charles Sutton’s manufactory stood on Ridge Avenue in Roxborough, just below Wissahickon Lane — in the creek-mouth mill row, the line of works along Ridge where the road meets Wissahickon Creek, at the edge of the village of Wissahickon Mills. Wissahickon Lane was the lane that ran from Ridge Avenue down toward the creek at that village; Sutton’s works stood on the avenue just below the lane’s mouth. That is where the record puts it, and the record is two lines long: two entries in the city directories, for 1857 and 1858, are the whole of it. No picture of it survives.

Nothing of the manufactory stands today. The ground is the Ridge Avenue corridor at the creek, and no source read for this story reports any part of the works standing.

Two lines in the directories

In 1857, McElroy’s Philadelphia city directory lists “Sutton Charles, manuf. R av bel Wissahickon la” — Charles Sutton, manufacturer, Ridge Avenue below Wissahickon Lane. In 1858 the directory lists him again: “Sutton Charles, manuf. R av (Rxbo)” — Ridge Avenue, Roxborough.

And that is all. “Manuf.” — manufacturer — is the only word the record gives for what went on there. The directories never say what Sutton made, what his building looked like, or what power turned his machinery. No source read describes any of it.

A manufacturer with no product

What Sutton produced is simply not in the record. No workforce, no output, and no power figures exist in anything read. The record that would most likely answer — the census of manufactures schedules for Roxborough and the 21st Ward — was not read. So the product stands printed as what it is: unspecified.

There is a guess, and it is printed as a guess. If the Charles Sutton of Ridge Avenue is the Charles H. Sutton who appears from 1859 in a Manayunk cloth firm — the question the next section takes up — then his trade was cloths and woolens, and the Ridge Avenue works of 1857–58 was most likely a small woolen or cloth works in the mill row. That is an inference from the other firm’s known trade. It is not this seat’s documented product.

One Charles Sutton, or two?

After 1858, no creek listing for Sutton appears again. What appears instead is a tidy trail in Manayunk: from 1859 to 1871 the directories carry the firm Sutton George & Son — George Sutton and Charles H. Sutton — makers of cloths and woolens on Main Street, Manayunk. The trail runs through 1859, 1860, 1864, 1867, and 1871.

One line in that trail leans back toward the creek. In 1867 the directory prints “Sutton Charles, wool manuf., Main, Myk, h Rox” — Charles Sutton, wool manufacturer, Main Street, Manayunk, house in Roxborough. The Manayunk Sutton worked across the river and lived in the same township where the 1857–58 manufactory stood.

So the records invite a merge, and nowhere prove it. Either the creek-mouth manufacturer of 1857–58 is Charles H. Sutton, who by 1859 was in his father’s Manayunk firm, and by 1867 was living in Roxborough while working in Manayunk — or there were two Charles Suttons. The records read do not decide it, and this account does not pretend to. Either way, there is no creek tie after 1858.

The end

No closing, sale, fire, or demolition of the manufactory is recorded in anything read. The directory presence simply ends after 1858 — which, on the one-man reading, is not a mill closing at all but a man moving to his father’s firm; on the two-men reading, it is a small works vanishing from the record.

The ground itself lay in the creek-mouth mill row that the Fairmount Park Commission swept after 1868, acquiring the valley’s mill sites and demolishing the works on them. That is the row’s documented fate, printed here as the setting. It is not this building’s proven end.

What could settle the story sits on paper, not online: the 1850 and 1860 census of manufactures schedules for Roxborough and the 21st Ward; the Park Commission’s briefs of title at the City Archives; and Macfarlan’s 1949 typescript on the Wissahickon mills, kept in the Free Library’s Map Room. Those stay unread, and the gaps stay printed.

No picture to show

This page carries no picture of the manufactory, because none exists to show. No drawing, photograph, or survey of Sutton’s works was found in any source read. The Hexamer insurance surveys, whose drawings picture so many of the creek’s mills, have no Sutton plate at the creek. So the page stands without a picture, rather than with one borrowed from another works.

Timeline

YearEventSource
1857“Sutton Charles, manuf. R av bel Wissahickon la” — Charles Sutton, manufacturer, Ridge Avenue below Wissahickon LaneMcElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1857
1858“Sutton Charles, manuf. R av (Rxbo)” — the last creek listingMcElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1858
1859–1871Sutton George & Son (George and Charles H. Sutton), cloths and woolens, Main Street, Manayunk — the trail that may or may not be this man’sMcElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1859–1871
1867“Sutton Charles, wool manuf., Main, Myk, h Rox” — the Manayunk Sutton’s house in RoxboroughMcElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1867

The Cellar

The research behind this story (read)

  1. Read in full: the seat on Ridge Avenue below Wissahickon Lane, at the edge of the Wissahickon Mills village; the two directory lines of 1857 and 1858; the product unspecified, with the woolen-or-cloth reading printed as an inference from the Manayunk firm’s trade; the standing conflict — one Charles Sutton or two — printed in full; the undocumented building, power, workforce, and end; the image attempt, with none located.

The directory record (read)

  1. McElroy’s Philadelphia City Directory, 1857 and 1858 (the Sutton lines), and the 1859–1871 Sutton George & Son trail — as read and transcribed.

Accounts of the creek mouth and the district (read)

  1. Jane Mork Gibson, Workshop of the World (1990), Fairmount Park chapter — context: the 1868 park acquisition of the creek-mouth sites (workshopoftheworld.com).
  2. Philadelphia Historical Commission, Ridge Avenue Roxborough Historic District nomination, “During and After the Civil War” section (via rmwhs.org) — context: the Commission’s systematic demolition of valley industry after 1868.

Image sources (checked)

  1. No image of Sutton’s manufactory: none found free, and none located behind permission either; the Hexamer indexed layer has no Sutton plate at the creek (checked via Philadelphia Architects and Buildings / GeoHistory). The image attempt stands: no image located, and none made up.

A note on sources. This account was researched online from the public record — deeds, maps, insurance surveys, directories, newspapers, and court reports — and every fact in it is tied to a source in the bibliography. Records from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are imperfect: names were spelled several ways, ages drift from census to census, and officials made mistakes. Where two records disagree, this account prints both rather than choosing silently; where an identification rests on converging evidence instead of a single document, it says so in the text. If you hold a record that corrects or extends this account, it is welcome here — corrections make the record better.

Back to The Mills

Back Home