The Amidown mill stood on Wissahickon Creek in the lower valley, in the reach between RittenhouseTown and the Monastery ground, toward Hermit’s Lane and Gorgas Lane. Even that placing needs its grade stated plainly: it rests on the order of the Fairmount Park Commission’s lot plans, not on any survey of the seat itself — an inference, printed as an inference. The mill is documented. Almost nothing else about it is. No record read for this story says what kind of mill it was, which bank it stood on, or what dam or race served it. And no picture of it survives: no drawing, photograph, or survey of the building was found in anything read. What survives is two records — and they disagree on the owner’s name.
Two records, two names
The first record is a list. In her Workshop of the World (1990), Jane Mork Gibson names the Wissahickon sites the Fairmount Park Commission began to acquire in 1868, and in the run of that list — after the Rittenhouse mill on the original seat, before Kitchen’s Mill — stand “the mills of Edward H. Amidown.”
The second record is a plan. The Commission’s lot plans, the park-taking plans that map the valley lot by lot, carry on sheet 15 a lot “formerly of Edmond H. Ammondown.”
Edward H. Amidown. Edmond H. Ammondown. Neither form is confirmed by any second record, and no third record exists online to break the tie. The name is a printed conflict, and it stands here unresolved — the same instability the mill list flags where it carries the seat under “Amidown.”
One more hint sits in Gibson’s wording, and it is only a hint. She writes “mills,” plural. That may mean the seat held more than one building, or it may be her list’s shorthand. It is the only suggestion anywhere that this seat held more than one mill, and it is printed as a hint, not a finding.
Where the seat stood
The lot plans run in valley order. Sheet 14 is the RittenhouseTown ground, in Charles Rittenhouse’s name. Sheet 16 is the Monastery ground, in Charles Thompson Jones’s name. Sheet 18 is Livezey’s, and sheet 20 is Bischoff’s. Sheet 15 — the Amidown lot — falls between RittenhouseTown and the Monastery, in the Hermit’s Lane and Gorgas Lane reach of the lower valley. Gibson’s list points the same way: her Amidown entry stands between the Rittenhouse mill on the original seat and Kitchen’s Mill, which worked the Monastery ground.
That is as far as the record goes. What kind of mill it was, which bank it stood on, what dam or race served it — not stated in anything read. Today the ground is parkland in the lower valley. No source read reports remains there, and no source read describes the building at all.
The working mill: nothing known
Of the mill at work, nothing is known from anything read. Not the kind of mill — grist, saw, paper, or textile. Not its size. Not its water. Not a single year of operation.
The silence is not for want of looking. A web search run for this mill, under “Amidown,” “Ammondown,” and “Edward H. Amidown,” with Wissahickon, mill, and Fairmount Park, returned no trace of the man or the mill under any spelling. The sister collection on this site, which writes the lives of the valley’s people, had already reached the same result: no census entry, no directory line, no deed, no tax line, no newspaper item under any spelling — and it removed the man as a subject for a life on exactly that ground: “NAME UNSTABLE, no trace under any spelling.”
The standard accounts of the valley do not carry this mill at all. A mill big enough to stand in Gibson’s acquisition list and on the Commission’s lot plans has left no other reachable trace. That silence, and the doubled name, are this story’s findings — honestly, they are nearly all of it.
The end
The end is the taking. Gibson places the Amidown mills among the sites the Commission began to acquire in 1868, and the lot stands on the Commission’s plans as a taken lot — “formerly of” its owner. The building is gone.
No record of this mill’s own demolition was read. Gibson gives the general pattern for the sites the city took: “Once taken over by the city, the buildings were torn down or became derelict and decayed over the years,” with the WPA in the 1930s demolishing or altering most of what remained. That pattern is the documented setting for this seat. It is printed here as context, not as this mill’s proven fate.
What could settle it
One paper record could answer nearly every question on this page. At the City Archives, the Fairmount Park Commission’s Index to Briefs of Title (RG 149.6, covering 1867–1962) holds a brief for each taken lot. The brief for the sheet-15 lot would carry the deed chain from the Penn patent down to the Commission’s purchase — and with it the owner’s true name, the mill’s description, and the price the city paid. A second paper source, Macfarlan’s 1949 typescript on the valley’s mills, kept in the Free Library’s Map Room, likely treats the seat as well.
Both sit on paper, not online. Both stand here as named, permanent gaps.
No picture to show
This page carries no picture of the Amidown mill, because none exists to show. No image of the mill was located, and none is known to exist in the sources read. So the page stands without a picture, rather than with one borrowed from another mill — or with a ruin some have guessed might be this seat, a guess no record proves.
Timeline
| Year | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1868 | The Fairmount Park Commission begins acquiring the Wissahickon mill sites; Gibson’s list of them includes “the mills of Edward H. Amidown” | Gibson, Workshop of the World, Fairmount Park chapter |
| The taking era | Sheet 15 of the Commission’s lot plans carries a lot “formerly of Edmond H. Ammondown,” between the RittenhouseTown ground (sheet 14) and the Monastery ground (sheet 16) | Fairmount Park Commission lot plans |
| After the taking | The building is gone; no demolition record for this mill was read. Gibson’s pattern for the taken sites — torn down or derelict, the WPA finishing most remains in the 1930s — is context, not this mill’s record | Gibson, as above |
